
UpFront: A Conversation with Amy Walter and Tamara Keith
Special | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
PBS News Hour's Politics Monday team breaks down the 2026 midterm election results.
PBS News Hour's Politics Monday team (Amy Walter from the Cook Political Report and NPR's Tamara Keith) breaks down the 2026 midterm election results. Recorded at the Jalbert Commons at Maine Public's Portland location.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Maine Public Original Productions is a local public television program presented by Maine PBS

UpFront: A Conversation with Amy Walter and Tamara Keith
Special | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
PBS News Hour's Politics Monday team (Amy Walter from the Cook Political Report and NPR's Tamara Keith) breaks down the 2026 midterm election results. Recorded at the Jalbert Commons at Maine Public's Portland location.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Maine Public Original Productions
Maine Public Original Productions is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
(dramatic music) - Hello, and welcome to this special edition of "Upfront."
We are coming to you from Maine Public's brand new building.
I'm Jennifer Rooks.
Our guests today need no introduction, especially for fans of the PBS News Hour.
You know Tamara Keith and Amy Walter from their regular insights and analysis on the segment, Politics Monday.
By the way, they have other jobs as well.
Amy Walter is the publisher and editor-in-chief of the Cook Political Report, and Tamara Keith is a senior political correspondent with NPR.
Tonight, we'll talk to them about the meaning of this midterm election, some analysis, and try to figure out what might be coming next.
And of course we're taking questions from members of the audience.
Those have been submitted in writing.
Welcome to both of you.
Welcome to Maine.
Welcome back.
- Yes.
- It strikes me that someday school kids are gonna study this, 2026.
- That's true.
- And I'm wondering, I think a lot of us who are living through it think this is an inflection point.
This is really an important moment in history.
There's gonna be a before and there's gonna be an after.
Is that right?
Is this as big a deal as it feels?
- It is... First of all, hello.
Hi, Maine.
Always happy to be here.
The last, I don't know, 10 or so years, we've been kind of trapped in this cementing of our political blue and red.
And it felt as if no event was going to be able to do anything to alter or to sort of unstick this polarization.
Think about, we had COVID, we had January 6th, we've had impeachments, we've had record high inflation.
We've had a president dropping out in July and for the first time that any of us have ever seen them get replaced by his vice president.
And these are big, big, massive events that in the sort of olden times or normal times, we would have thought would shift voter behavior significantly.
And instead, all of our races have been fought on this very, very narrow playing field.
Handful of states determine who the president is, a handful of states determine who controls the Senate, handful of districts determines who controls the House.
And for the first time in many years, that polarization has broken apart.
And you see one side, obviously this is Democratic side, going deep into red territory in a way we really haven't seen in many years.
And in fact, the popular vote margin right now is over 13 points.
Last time I checked, it was 13.6% of voter, by a 13.6% margin, voters preferred a Democrat in the House to a Republican.
That's a national vote.
We haven't seen anything like that in 50 years.
So it is an inflection point in that sense where voters were clearly saying, "We're really unhappy with the way things are going and we're gonna let you know about it in a way we hadn't seen before."
At the same time, and this is what we're all gonna have to be patient for a little while, we're gonna wait until we get real data back from all the different states once they put all their voter files together and certify all the votes, data analysts are gonna go in there, take that data and try to understand who actually showed up to vote and who didn't.
Because what we're gonna have to figure out is, was this huge gulf about voters really deciding, "You know what?
I've been voting for Republicans.
I supported Trump, but now I'm switching and I'm voting for Democrats."
How much of it was that?
And how much of it was Democrats really excited to show up and vote?
And Republicans still being Republicans, but deciding that their way of showing a protest was to stay home.
So it's not that they're saying, "I'm supporting Democrats," as much as they were saying, "I just can't support Republicans."
So while it made a huge difference in this election, I don't know that it has fundamentally altered the way that people see themselves as part of the red team or the blue team.
- Tamara, I see you nodding away.
- Yes.
Amy's right about everything.
Amy's always right.
(audience laughing) - No.
- (laughs) It's true.
- Tell my son that.
- Yes, right.
And then you could tell my son that I'm always right.
- Yeah.
- And then we'll work.
You know, this is the largest Democratic wave since 1974.
And what happened then?
These were the Watergate babies that came in.
And it created this dramatic shift in politics.
And then Ronald Reagan became president six years later or whatever.
So it definitely seems like a moment.
It seems like a moment when a fairly large share of the electorate is hungry for change.
Though honestly, the electorate has been begging for change every two years, and then they've been disappointed every two years.
I am still recovering from being a White House correspondent, but early in this Trump term, in the second Trump term, I kept doing these stories about this law that he barreled past.
And it was always a law passed in the post-Watergate era.
All of these good government reforms that were passed by these young new members of Congress that came in to clean things up in Washington.
And, you know, for 40 years, those laws held until they didn't.
So I don't know if we're going to get a new period of government reform and good government changes and, you know, efforts to reign in some of the excesses, or if this is a completely different environment and there's no Gerald Ford to sign the bills.
And I think that there is a very large risk that voters who voted for change are instead going to get two years of gridlock and then they're gonna be mad again.
- [Amy] Uh-huh.
(indistinct) - Well, I wanted to ask you, you said voters voted for change.
And I know I've been reading a lot about the polls that say people were focused on the cost of groceries and gas and maybe a little bit some other issues, reproductive rights, corruption, the war in Iran.
But I'm wondering if it's about something that's also a little harder to quantify about what it means to be an American, what it means to be a citizen.
I mean, it's such a sea change and at least on its surface, when you look at who was elected, it seems like a very different group of people that are coming in as freshmen, senators and congressmen.
So I'm wondering, and I'll start with you, Tam, is that just too, I don't know, woo-woo, this is what it means to be an American?
- That is very lofty of you.
(audience laughing) I think that based on what I... You know, I spend a lot of time talking to swing voters.
I have this project called Swing Shift.
These are people who voted for Biden and then voted for Trump or they've swung around.
And the message I got from pretty much everybody was, "I'm tired.
I'm exhausted.
I'm tired of the drama.
I'm tired of the prices.
I'm tired of the corruption.
I'm tired of feeling like, you know, the political class gets ahead and I can't get by."
So, you know, I don't know if this was a vote for, you know, uplifting the great American ideal as much as it was a vote to say, "Whatever we're doing right now just isn't sustainable."
- But it was in many ways a pushback on overreach and excess, right?
And the fact that you had, especially in the South, the Black turnout in the states that were redrawn after the overturning of the Voting Rights Act is what brought a Democratic and the first Black senator to Mississippi since Reconstruction.
It's what brought the first female Black former mayor and now governor of Georgia.
Louisiana Senate became, it was incredibly close.
That was just a two or three-point race there.
And then North Carolina shifting, not just 13, 14 points to Democrats at the Senate side, but the redraw in that state basically cost almost every single Republican member of that delegation their seat, including districts that hadn't been redrawn, right?
So the back, when we keep saying, "Well, How can voters..." Right?
We feel helpless.
We feel like nobody's listening to us.
You guys just go in there and you redrew these lines.
The Supreme Court just decides that the Voting Rights Act, they can just nullify parts of it.
We should be doing something about it.
- People did.
- And they did.
And so in that sense, yes, it is a lofty concept, right?
The voters can actually weigh in on these things.
Now, does this mean that what it means is that everybody agrees with this?
No, but the people who showed up were the ones that were the most, exactly.
- And, Tam, as you said, you were talking to swing voters, but what about the motivated Democrats who didn't vote before and, you know?
- Certainly they're, I mean, you know, in a state like Mississippi, for instance, I think a lot of people were like, "Well, what does my vote count?
It always turns out this one way."
And in this election, there was a huge amount of on-the-ground organizing, Black women going out and talking to people and saying, "No, you really have to vote."
And there had also been a purging of the voter rolls, which I think upset people.
It turns out that if you try to disenfranchise people, they don't like it.
(audience laughing) Which is- - That's what I was getting at.
- Yeah.
- And you're saying it much better than I was asking.
And that's what I was getting at.
One of the things that made people say, "Wait a minute, this isn't my country."
- Yeah, but I would also say that there is also just some cold hard politics too.
For instance, in Georgia, Republicans fielded a Senate candidate who was not great.
In North Carolina, Republicans fielded a Senate candidate who was pretty uninspiring to Republican voters.
Both of them were picked by President Trump and he thought that he could pull them over the finish line with, you know, just in- - South Carolina.
- Just have more rallies, South Carolina too.
And, like, if there had been a competitive Senate race in Georgia or a competitive Senate race in North Carolina, you wouldn't have seen this Democratic sweep.
You wouldn't have seen... North Carolina is just stunning to me.
I've spent a fair bit of time there over the last several years.
I went and covered a Trump rally that was held in Greenville, North Carolina, which was drawn out of one congressman's district and handed to another congressman so that basically there was an African American congressman that represented North Carolina's first district.
He's very popular and they were trying to get him out.
And the president went there to rally and everyone who appeared at that rally lost.
And the congressman who refused to show up because he was actually worried about his race also lost.
All of the Republicans lost.
And it went from a 10-4 Republican to Democratic delegation to it appears as though it is going to be an 11-3, 11 Democrats, 3 Republicans.
And this is the state that has most aggressively gerrymandered for years.
They've been doing mid-decade gerrymandering like it was going out of style, and, you know, they flew too close to the sun.
So part of it is, yes, you can't disenfranchise me.
And part of it is Republicans nominated an uninspiring candidate.
They had to triage.
They took the money out of North Carolina and sent it to Texas and Kansas, lost there too, but they were not on the air.
They were not organizing.
They weren't trying to win in North Carolina, and it has a down-ballot effect all the way to breaking a Republican super majority in the legislature, Democrats taking over the House.
Like, they might even end up, it's very close to a tie in the Senate in North Carolina, that's wild.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
- How many times have you said, "That's wild?"
(laughs) - How many times did I see it on air on Tuesday night?
(laughs) - You know, here in Maine, Senator Susan Collins was defeated after serving the state for 30 years.
Some analysts have suggested that Troy Jackson won primarily because of the anti-Trump blue wave surge.
And to me, that kinda suggests that they think any Democrat could have beaten Susan Collins.
And I'm wondering if you think that's the case or if you think that narrative sells him short?
- And I think it sells Susan Collins short as well.
Look, part of the reason that Democrats never felt totally confident about Maine is really because of Susan Collins, less a bit about the Democratic candidate.
And obviously, all of the drama and tumult that happened in this state over the summer didn't help.
But when we were backstage, we were just looking at, like for example, the North Carolina Senate race or the Georgia Senate race.
So North Carolina and Georgia, a lot redder than Maine.
Susan Collins got 47% of the vote here.
The candidate in Georgia got 39%.
The candidate in North Carolina... No, the candidate in North Carolina got 39%.
That is a state Trump carried by three points.
This is a state that Biden, Harris, Clinton all carried by seven, eight, nine points.
So her over-performance... Now, again, you can parse this a million different ways, right?
Would her number have been lower had there been a different Democratic candidate?
None of that I really think matters.
I do think that the challenge always, and you all are voters here, so you understand this better than anybody, but Collins' challenge was that in 2020, she was able to be seen as somebody who could go in, be effective at her job, and for people who... So you could, as a voter, vote for her and support her, but you could also vote against Donald Trump.
You could vote for Joe Biden and that was your vote against Donald Trump.
And then you could kinda have both things.
You get the senator who's gonna do the work for you, that you like what she's providing, and saying no to Trump.
Here, you didn't have any choice.
If you wanted to say no to Trump, you did have to vote against Susan Collins.
And the weight of that, I think, was ultimately too much for her to handle.
You know, we saw this in states that Democrats had been going against the tide for years, like in Montana where Jon Tester was winning and winning and winning even as the state was getting redder and redder and redder, and then eventually the weight of that just became too much.
- Tam, you know that our Senate race had a lot of negativity and- - It did.
- It seems to have backfired.
- Yes, and I think that this wasn't just your Senate race.
This was an across the board Republican strategy.
I attended the, or I didn't attend, I covered the midterm convention in Dallas and every speech was, you know, it's common sense versus crazy.
And there was a lot of focus on sort of culture war type issues.
And that can work if you're not in power and people are mad about the economy.
It doesn't work as well if you're in power and people are mad about the economy.
But the whole strategy across the board in every one of these Senate races was to disqualify the Democrat, to other the Democrat, to make the Democrat scary.
And obviously it didn't work anywhere, but it was a concerted effort.
And obviously, yes, you did have some negative campaign ads here and, you know, some that were sort of condescending.
- Since it didn't work, it means we're never gonna see any negative campaign.
- Sure.
- Yeah.
Also, like did it get up to like $13 billion that was spent on campaign ads nationwide in all the races?
And it turns out money can't buy you love.
The analysis I had seen is that Democrats were vastly outspent, but early at the right times, they were actually running positive ads, intro ads, sort of laying out who their candidates were so that people felt like they knew them.
And then when you get towards the end and it's just this barrage of negative ads, it has less of an effect.
And also, I think voters have a tendency to look at a negative ad and go, "Well, these all must be lies."
- Yeah, and I do think that, look, again, Collins was up against this massive headwind, and the one thing she had going for her was this idea that she could deliver for the state in a way that nobody else could.
And so you had to make people think, boy, if you get rid of me, right, what you're gonna get instead is somebody who's not gonna be able to provide nearly what I can, and hence the Cord of Wood ad, et cetera.
And that really was the only play that she had.
I will say it's also one of the few states, as Tam was pointing out, there was so much negative advertising all across the country.
But when I looked at places like Texas, Iowa, some of these deep red states, the Democratic candidates' overall approval ratings were really high, and they were much higher than the approval ratings of the party.
Maine was one of the few states where the Democratic candidate was seen as negatively as the Republican.
And so if you're saying, did it work?
Well, it did, in that sense.
- Right.
- It was effective in raising questions.
This is what that campaign had to do, was raise enough questions in the minds of people who don't like Donald Trump, wanted to see a change in Washington, were angry at Collins, but she had to raise that question mark, "Is this the person you really wanna replace me with?
You may be mad at me, right?
But this, that's what you're gonna do, okay."
- Well, let's talk about Troy Jackson because he will be the only blue collar senator in the US Senate, right?
I mean, he hasn't gotten a lot of attention nationally because there's so many other - - There's so many stories.
Yes.
- Historic moments being made, but this is really unusual, right?
And I'm wondering, you all have spent a lot of time on the Hill, how do you think he'll be received and viewed by the rest of the US Senate?
- I think it's gonna be fascinating.
You're right.
Reporters are gonna decide which... Well, Tam knows this very well, is covering Congress up there.
The people that get the most attention are usually the ones who are willing to talk to the media, right?
And so they put themselves out there.
And then if they have a great folksy quip or two, or they're the ones that spill a lot of tea, or they just happen to be the ones that are getting in fights with leadership, that's where all the reporters go.
You'll see these scrums on Capitol Hill around the people who will give the most dramatic, most inflammatory, most showy sort of quotes.
- This is like Senator John Kennedy from Louisiana.
- Exactly.
- Gets so much attention- - Gets so much attention.
And then there are those who do a lot of work, but, you know, Jon Ossoff doesn't talk to the media at all.
So for as much attention as he's getting as a figure, national figure, he's not somebody on Capitol Hill that is eager to be, he doesn't - - There's show horses and there's workhorses.
- Yes, and there's just people who wanna do that.
So some of that will be who decides to interact there or not.
And then we're gonna see what kind of path that he cuts.
I mean, if there's a through line in this election, you're right, he's the only person who truly can say, "This guy comes from a real blue collar background.
There's not another longer in the United States Senate."
But look at that Senate class that came in.
One of them is a pastor and started a mega church in Kansas.
Not your typical path to politics.
James Talarico is a state rep, but really now spends as much time talking about being a seminarian.
- [Jennifer] He was a middle school teacher too.
- And was a middle school teacher.
The new senator from South Carolina is a physician.
This was a class coming in, so he actually fits quite well into that, which is we are, even though he was in the state senate, he's not new to politics, but his story of being somebody who's, like, on the outside looking in, it fits with a lot of this class.
And that's where it really does share the Watergate baby comparison.
A lot of folks who were really truly outsiders coming in and then telling voters, "What I'm gonna do is come change the system."
It was not just about Donald Trump.
This election was about changing the system more than it was about just being a check on the president.
- Yeah, I think that the candidates, the Democratic candidates this cycle had much more to their message than just an anti-Trump.
They weren't even necessarily running on being a check on Trump as much as they were running on, you know, "This just isn't right," or, "Things are really expensive" or Scott Colom had this incredible ad in Mississippi where, you know, "Pick another protein.
I'd like to pick another senator."
Like that is probably the best campaign ad of the century.
I mean, it's a short century so far, but it just cut right to the message, which is sort of a... I mean, there is a populism to it.
If you listen to James Talarico, lots of people sort of perceive him as being moderate because he was theoretically the more moderate candidate in that primary.
He's the seminarian.
If you like gave him a Vermont, not Vermont, gave him a Brooklyn accent, he could be Bernie Sanders.
The words that he is saying frequently, you know, it's not about left versus right, it's top versus bottom.
Like all of this stuff is very much in line with what Bernie Sanders has been saying since he was the mayor of Burlington.
- Yeah, very much.
- We will get to these in just a second, but I have to ask you about Hannah and Chellie Pingree.
I spoke with Rutgers' Center for American Women in Politics last week.
They say this has never happened before in America that a mother and daughter are serving simultaneously- - Which is... - Is such- - Yeah.
Are you surprised?
(panelists and audience laughing) I mean, we don't have a lot of women doing these jobs, but it's- - What's so interesting to me, y'all, is that they don't talk about this.
They almost don't even acknowledge it.
And I'm wondering sort of, do you all think this is a really big deal?
- I actually, on election night, and then you can talk to the Pingrees, but on election night, I was doing our race calls for NPR, which meant that I was the one who would go on the air and say, so-and-so has won this race, and this is what it means.
And I hadn't fully processed how much history was going to be made on election night because, again, candidates weren't running on making history.
- They weren't the only one.
- That was so 2016.
Now, you know, this was a campaign about so many things, and then all of a sudden, "Oh, this person's making history.
Oh, this is the first Black governor here.
This is the first Black governor here."
Like, so much history was being made that (chuckles)- - That's right.
- This too.
- That's right.
I think that is exactly it.
That there was not a leaning into identity in the way that you might have seen at other times, you know?
And I think there was a lesson learned by Democrats from watching Hillary Clinton running on, "I'm gonna be the first woman," right?
Much of the theme of that campaign was, "Help me make history."
And what a lot of voters were saying was, "Okay, that's great.
Like, history, cool, but what we want you is to work for us."
- Yeah.
- Right?
That's what a politician does.
And that I think what Democrats did very well, they didn't wanna allow Republicans to get into the identity game, right, about, "Oh, we're gonna shift the focus off of affordability onto cultural issues, identity issues, race issues.
We're not gonna allow them that opportunity to do that.
We're gonna stay laser focused.
Affordability, corruption, changing the system, that's all we're gonna talk about."
And they were incredibly successful doing that.
Now they have to be as successful doing that in Congress as they were on the campaign trail, and it's going to be a different kettle of fish.
- Well, we are so used to, you know, fathers and sons.
- Yes.
- John Adams, John Quincy Adams, the Bushes, the Sununus in New Hampshire.
You all could probably add 25.
And so I just wonder if you think it's as big of a deal as it seems to me.
- I do think it's a big deal, right?
And I think maybe this is what you're gonna see more of is as you have more and more women.
Yeah, I mean, we were just talking about Senator Jeanne Shaheen next door, her daughter's now in Congress.
Now, it's also not a great time... By the way, people also don't love dynasties.
- Right.
- The way they used to.
- That's right.
- You know?
Not a big fan.
So maybe that's also a... Let's just put it on the... - But how many women are in this new class?
- Yeah, I don't know the number, but it's - - I feel like it was something like a hundred.
I just kept thinking... Amy and I play in a softball game.
It's media against female members of Congress, and it's always had to be media versus Congress 'cause they couldn't field a big enough team with... They couldn't field... They couldn't have Democrats versus Republicans 'cause they couldn't field enough of them.
And I'm like, "With a hundred- - You can find some.
- You can find a softball team.
- Yeah.
- Yeah, I'm a little concerned that they might have improved their rates- - They definitely did, because there are a lot of young women in there.
That's the problem.
(audience laughing) They got a lot of young women.
- Sure did.
- I have a feeling you're both pretty good softball players.
- Our team is always so, what's hilarious, so this is a fundraising event raising money for young women.
Thank you, this was started, it was a bipartisan group started by Debbie Wasserman Schultz, who's a congresswoman from Florida and Jo Ann Emerson, who's a Republican from Missouri, both who were breast cancer survivors.
And so this game is going on six... - 16 - 16 years?
And it is pretty funny because when we look at, well, what is the biggest challenge for the press team?
What's the biggest challenge for the members team?
For the press team, someone's always pregnant.
That's always our problem.
It's like, oh, okay, you were being one of them.
So we lose our great players like the shortstop this year.
It's like, what?
Can't you plan better?
- Well, yeah.
- Not during the season.
- I brought the baby to the dugout and I played half the game, had to nurse.
(Amy and audience laughing) (Tamara laughs) This was eight years ago.
- For the members, it's that they lose.
- Yeah.
- Right?
Their worry is that their best player could lose reelection.
- Yes.
- So I consider that basically the same thing.
- The blue wave definitely helped their team.
- The blue wave definitely helped their team.
That's true.
- Because there were some longtime players who- - Who were at risk.
- Who should have been re-districted out of their jobs.
But then the wave came.
- [Amy] Mm-hmm.
- I'm gonna get to some of your questions.
And this is one that has been asked in a few different ways.
What should the Democrats keep top of mind so that they don't waste the opportunity this election has given them?
- I'll go, it's interesting.
We talked about this a little bit on Politics Monday.
These swing voters that I talked to, their message is pretty uniform.
Like, we don't want two years of partisan bickering.
Like we do not want impeachments.
Like investigations, fine, but, like, let's just keep the temperature down and actually accomplish something.
We voted for you to accomplish something.
I got a message on Facebook, which is how I always hear from people who are mad at me.
I never otherwise go on there.
And the person who wrote in was like, "That doesn't represent me.
I want revenge."
- [Amy] Yes, yes.
Yes.
- And that is a real tension that Democrats are going to have to deal with because there are a lot of voters who are like, "There has been rampant corruption and we would like to see that dealt with."
And then there are people who just want to be able to pay for their electric bill or their heating bill.
And it's a real challenge.
And, you know, the other factor is the president who has the ultimate veto.
And obviously they are setting up a very confrontational posture with regards to investigations at this point, basically saying, "We'll prosecute you for investigating us," which is legally dubious, but sets the tone.
- Right.
- And I think that, you know, in the first term, there had been a brief glimmer of, "Well, maybe there are some bipartisan things we should work on."
And then the impeachment started and they were like, "Well, we can't work with Democrats if they're going to impeach us, so we're done."
And I think that is a... (chuckles) I don't know that... Democrats are not talking about impeachment.
Elected Democrats are not talking about impeachment.
They said that they were elected to get things done other than impeachment, but I think that the president is looking for a reason not to blame all- - Yeah, and he also loves a foil.
He does much better when he has a foil.
He is a hammer, everything is a nail.
That is what he wants to be able to do.
And I think putting Stephen Miller as chief of staff said exactly that, which is, "It's not just, we're not really interested in compromise.
It's, we're gonna come at you with everything to try to throw you off balance, right, so that if you think you're calling the shots, you think you're gonna send me bills.
Oh, really?
Well, I'm gonna go do executive orders."
And then that's gonna get to Tam's point of the, "I want revenge, I want retribution."
Those voters say, "What are you doing?
Why are you allowing him to do that?"
Well, actually what we're trying to do is get a messaging bill done on the healthcare, right?
Well, he's not gonna sign it.
So who cares about that?
You guys working on all this legislation on affordability that he won't sign, go stop him from doing this other stuff.
How come you're not stopping him?
How come you're not doing more?
And the fact that House Republicans put Jim Jordan as their leader, again, not somebody who is particularly interested in saying, you're right, the message, I mean, again, the message from the election was pretty clear, right?
Affordability, top issue.
Putting Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan as your front facing members of the minority party in Congress, and of course the White House says, "Well, actually, that's not what we really wanna be talking about.
What we wanna do is fight on our turf and we can put executive orders.
We can do all sorts of things that are gonna take you off your talking points and come play on our territory."
- And Jim Jordan is someone who I believe has not authored a single bill that has become law and he's been in Congress for 20 years.
Now there are lots of people who don't succeed at getting bills into law, but it's an indication that he has not been a deal maker.
He's never been part of a gang of whatever number.
Susan Collins, on the other hand, member of many gangs.
She... (chuckles) - Right.
You gotta clarify what that means.
I would love if they clip this and they're like, "Oh my gosh, Tamara Keith said Susan Collins is a member of gangs."
(audience laughing) That's negative campaigning.
What?
- For whatever reason, in the Senate generally, they are trying to come to some sort of bipartisan agreement.
It is always a gang of some number of senators, some large enough number to actually move things.
But yes.
(chuckles) - Well, here are two related questions.
Is this the moment?
Has the torch finally been passed to a new generation?
And do you see the shift in age of the newly elected Congress as consequential?
- Okay.
Can I just say something about this?
- Yes.
- Yeah, my hobby horse, you know what my hobby horse is.
Okay.
Yeah, like, okay, great.
Millennials, happy for you.
What about us?
What about the Gen Xers that are getting totally overlooked?
We are gonna get passed by as we always do because whatever, fine, we don't even care.
- [Tamara] They have shrunk our generation.
- Oh my God.
- There's creep.
There's like millennial creep.
- So this is the whole... (audience laughing) Now we're gonna have to hear, like, all we heard about growing up, right?
The boomers stayed around too long.
We now finally have our chance and now here come the millennials, boom, knocking us down.
- Gen Z.
- And the Gen Zers- - So it's like you're telling me is Congress is gonna be full of boomers and millennials.
- And the Xers are there in theory.
Look, there is a Gen X speaker of the house in Hakeem Jeffries.
There is a Gen Xer, runs the DSCC in Kirsten Gillibrand.
They're in positions of leadership.
But if you're looking at the torch being passed, it's being passed to that generation.
And I think that's right.
I mean, the most talked about Democrat right now running for president is Jon Ossoff.
And after that- - And he's millennial.
- And he's very millennial.
Pete Buttigieg, millennial.
AOC, millennial, right?
Now, my people, my Gen Xers, there have been people that you know that have been on the scene for a long time, Gavin Newsom, Gretchen Whitmer, Josh Shapiro, right?
Cory Booker, all of those folks.
But there is no doubt that the challenge for the Xers is they now are the status quo.
They are the establishment, which I cannot believe we're the man now, but whatever.
(audience laughing) (Tamara laughs) Anyway, we're the status quo and that generation of millennials is coming in at the kinda perfect time of people desperate for a new perspective.
And, and here's what's really important.
I'm a big believer, even though I'm lamenting younger people.
But as parents of Z... Are you... - I don't know what my children are.
- Yours is Z.
- Well, I have a 14-year-old.
- The youngest is an alpha.
- He's an alpha.
He's definitely... - Anyway, as a parent of a Z-er, I have long believed, and this is what's great about this generation.
Look, they are our digital generation and the younger millennials are as well.
And like that's where... They understand where the world is going.
They understand how we're gonna transform from this, like we're half in the 21st century, but we're really, our institutions are way in the 20th century.
They're still in that mode.
They're the only ones that can really help take us there.
Now it's not to say that somebody in their 50s can't talk about technology, but I'm saying there's a nativeness to them that because this is all they know, they're just so much more comfortable with it.
And I think that is also what people are looking for.
We didn't talk about AI that much- - I was about to say, you mean you don't want the boomers writing legislation about AI?
(audience laughing) (Amy laughs) - There was somebody went around on the Hill asking who had even used AI, and most of the senators were like, "A what?"
(audience laughing) (Tamara chuckles) - [Amy] Right.
- It's a challenge, though I have a colleague who did the calculation, so don't hold me to it.
I think the average age of Congress is only coming down by three years, despite this infusion of youth.
- [Amy] Of youth, yeah.
- And similarly with the Watergate babies, it didn't come down by as much as you would think it did.
- [Amy] Right.
Right.
Whoever asked that last question, thank you.
That brought it out.
Yeah, yeah.
- I'm sorry.
You just went on my... (speaking indistinctly) - Okay.
- Go put on your flannel.
- I know.
- Combat boots.
- I know it.
And go watch grunge.
- Go listen to some Pearl Jam.
- That's what I'm saying.
- Tam, what is the future of ICE?
- Oh, fun.
(audience laughing) (Jennifer laughing) (Tamara chuckles) You know, early this year, there was something resembling a bipartisan agreement that ICE needed some guardrails and needed to be reigned in because of the obvious abuses.
And the New York Times has a story out about the person who was involved in the ICE-involved shooting here, and his mom doesn't have nice things to say about him.
- [Amy] Right.
- I think that there was a huge infusion of cash, a huge rush to surge ICE agents into American communities- - Without any guardrails.
- And without any guardrails.
And that is another theme of this election, is people were happy with President Trump closing the border, but people were not happy with the enforcement in the interior of the country.
They thought it was overreach.
People are upset about it, and you saw huge movement among Latino voters in Florida and in Texas.
And that's not just about immigration enforcement, it's also about the economy.
And so all of that is to say that I think that at some point, Congress is going to figure out a way to have some guardrails.
You know, body-worn cameras actually have to be body worn.
Maybe you can't shoot into moving vehicles.
Just some basic small things that they could agree on.
The challenge though is Stephen Miller as chief of staff, when there was a gang of eight, I bring back the gangs again, there was an effort to pass bipartisan immigration reform that involved citizenship for the dreamers, the young people who have been brought to the country as children.
This is 2014.
Stephen Miller personally worked to sink that legislation when he was an aid.
I don't know if it was on the House side or the Senate.
I think he was on the Senate side, but he like sent stuff to House members and sank it in the House.
So all of this is to say he is not someone who wants any guardrails, any sort of reform of any kind, any sort of legalization.
President Trump, you saw him on "60 Minutes" sort of talking a gentle talk about, "Well, maybe we did go too far.
Maybe we should do something for people who are just law abiding."
And the backlash he got from the right was significant.
I think that one thing that has happened with this huge blue wave is that the more moderate members of Congress, the ones who would be interested in making a deal or compromising- - They're all gone.
- Are not going to be there on the Republican side.
(indistinct) - Where do you see the leadership of either party going?
You guys talked about the Republicans already.
- What happens next on the Democratic side?
- Sure.
- I guess the question is what leadership means at this point.
Yes, there's going to be a Democratic leader, Chuck Schumer in the Senate and in the House, it's Hakeem Jeffries.
But really, 2027 and 2020 is all about who's gonna be the leader of the Democratic Party as the nominee for president.
And there are gonna be approximately, what, 600,000 Democrats.
- At least 29.
They will need a bus.
They cannot fit in a van.
- Yeah, you're not gonna be able to do a debate.
You're gonna have to have like- - Six debates.
- This entire place filled just to do one debate of candidates.
So the future, you know, again, we, as people who live in Washington, we love to think that the future is really all about what's going on in Congress and the White House.
It's for what's gonna be facing voters and what they're gonna get deluged with.
And they already have, if you're sitting in a swing state, if you're in South Carolina, if you're in New Hampshire, although that's not really now an early state, if you're in Nevada, Arizona, you've already seen a ton of these candidates come in and it's only gonna increase as it goes on.
So they're each gonna try to put up, "Here's what the Democratic message is.
I am the leader of the party."
So until that person's chosen, the actual leadership of the party is going to be in the hands of the Schumers and Jeffries.
But once we get the campaign going... - What do you think the new Congress should do first to set the stage for Medicare for All legislation?
- Well, don't they have to... Well, first, the Democratic Party has to agree on what that looks like.
What's interesting is you've got... Tam is right, especially on the Senate side.
If you just listened to all of the ads that the candidates were running, and I didn't tell you what state they were running in, didn't tell you anything else about them.
They all sort of took a similar approach, right?
It's not left and right, it's top down.
It's them, you know, pushing us down.
It's the system that's the problem, not just the person.
We need to take on these big institutions, whether it is pharma, whether it is- - AI.
- Right, so there is a desire across the board and everyone starts with, and healthcare's too expensive.
Now what does Medicare for All actually look like in the form that it takes?
And I think the challenge, and Democrats have often fallen to this, I was talking to, right before the election, somebody who works really closely with Democrats as Democratic strategists, and it's like the problem that we have is, again, we're having this conversation, right?
And we're gonna get wrapped around the axle and have policy debate... We're going to get caught in process.
What do you want?
What do you want?
What do you need?
What do you need?
And we're gonna get caught in this process.
We're gonna be fighting amongst ourselves.
And that's the story.
It's gonna be a process story about this issue rather than just saying, "Hey, we just introduced legislation.
Let the president veto it that says ACA subsidies have to be put back in, that the Medicaid cuts have to be rescinded."
That's number one, right?
Just go start with that.
- So how are you so certain that they're not gonna do the second, that they're gonna do the first, that they're gonna get wrapped up in process?
- Because they often do.
- (chuckles) Yeah.
- It's a hard thing, but what is Medicare for All?
So when we ask voters, this is what's fascinating.
Like we asked this in a poll we took earlier this fall in the most competitive congressional districts in the country, we said, "All right, well, what do you think about like socialism when you hear that?"
"Eh, I don't really like that."
"Okay.
What about Medicare for All?"
"Oh, that's great.
Love it."
"Okay.
What about capitalism?"
"Yeah, good.
It's pretty good."
"All right.
Should we tax billionaires?"
"Of course," right?
And so these are all sort of amorphous ideas.
Literally taking Medicare for all, right?
Look what it took to get the ACA through.
- Right.
- Yeah.
- That was a year, almost two-year process when Democrats had 60 Senate seats and a 40-seat majority, and they barely got that done.
And a president.
- Yes, well, and they basically have been trying to recover from the midterm after that.
- Yeah, ever since.
- Ever since.
- So is there room... This is why I think so many of these big policy debates, it is, again, I don't know what they're gonna do, but I think there is, at least from folks I talked to, a desire for Congress to do the things that they can do today with a Republican president, that they can talk about the voters that Tam mentioned, the swing voters who said, "I want results today.
Things are expensive for me today.
I don't wanna wait for Medicare for All."
If you're gonna do anything, make sure that you... Because these Medicaid cuts haven't even really kicked in yet.
I mean, you guys- - SNAP cuts.
- And the SNAP cuts, like in Maine and in so many other communities, the problems that have begun this year with closing down rural hospitals or closing down certain, you know, we don't have a maternal center here and you have to drive to this town to go get that, that was not because of Medicaid cuts, that's because they are preparing for that.
So that hasn't even really hit.
If you were going to do something as a legislator that can actually have immediate impact and that put it on the president's plate rather than getting in a battle about what it means, what does it really mean to have Medicare for all and all of the challenges that come with recreating a system.
- So do you think it's more practical and more feasible that they're going to propose just rescinding the Medic... - I mean, I think that's- - That's the most likely- - Item number one is resending the Medicaid cuts and extending the Obamacare subsidies, which there were bipartisan repercussions about that too- - That was supposed to happen.
- That was actually supposed to happen and then it fell apart.
I think like the sort of next step, pie in the sky for people who want Medicare for All is probably expanding Medicare down to 55.
- Yeah, right.
Right.
- Which would solve a lot of the insurance market problems for people.
Like the real Obamacare premium problems are coming in that age range where people thought they could retire early and then- - They get the bill.
- They they went to buy insurance.
- Where do Democrats stand to win in 2028?
I know I wanted to end with a prediction.
- Oh, well, you mean, are you talking about like for everything?
- Oh, for the president?
- I don't know.
I didn't ask the question- - Whether they're gonna win in Texas at the presidential level?
Is that what you're trying to get to- - It can be whatever you want.
- It can be whatever you want.
- It's a Rorschach test.
Go.
- Well, so here's the thing with a giant blue wave.
I'm gonna take it in a different direction.
So all of these House members are gonna be on the ballot again in two years.
And many of these House members won in districts where just two years earlier, the Republican president won by 10 points, 15 points, 20 points.
There are going to be a lot of House members, Democratic House members who have extremely difficult races.
And I think that the question that all of them probably have also is, are we renting these voters or did we get them forever?
And I don't think that they fully know the answer, but the next two years will define that.
I do think that in a presidential year, the top of the ticket gets all of the attention, the top of the ticket gets all of the resources.
I do think that things are scrambled.
You know, there have only been eight states that have gotten any presidential campaign ads in the last, since President Trump... I mean, I guess like, I remember covering the Clinton campaign and going to Florida and Ohio, and then afterwards everybody was like, "Well, that was dumb of her."
- Never going there again.
- Never going there again.
- In Iowa.
- And now... In Iowa.
And yet now, Iowa has a Democratic Senator, Ohio has a Democrat- - I see your point because recently we've gotten into these cycles where we go to the same states, and what the political scientists will say, it's the same counties in the same states.
And now you're saying that's all changed?
- It might be all changed.
I think that there are a lot of people who are a lot smarter about campaign strategy than I am who are going to have to figure that out because if a Democrat can win in Texas up and down the ballot, then can Democrats ignore Texas and focus on the blue wall?
- They can't ignore it.
I mean, I think the lesson is exactly that, which is if you just look, go ahead past 2028, go into 2030, and then the reapportionment that comes with the census, California is gonna lose seats.
New York is gonna lose seats.
A lot of those blue wall states are gonna lose seats.
Where are they going?
Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Georgia.
Okay, the best thing that happened, I think, for Democrats was not just winning Texas, but to win North Carolina as handily as they did, to win Georgia as handily as they did.
The fast-growing states in the Southwest, you know, that's where Democrats have to compete because if you look at the map that Kamala Harris ran on, and she could have won if she had just carried right, it was all about, well, you can lose all everything else, but just win the blue wall and then lost the blue wall.
You can't win with just the blue wall in 2032.
You have to be able to get into those Sunbelt states.
And Texas right now has 40 electoral votes.
It'll probably have 42 electoral votes by 2032, if not more.
- And more congressional districts.
- That's right.
- Yeah.
- And so that's why you can't ignore either one, Texas or Florida, the two fastest growing states in the country as a party.
And you say, "Well, we're just gonna seed those to the other side, and we're gonna try to patch together enough states with 270."
That's not gonna last very long.
- This has been so fun.
- It's been great.
- Thank you both.
Tamara Keith, senior political correspondent with NPR, Amy Walter, publisher and editor-in-chief of the Cook Political Report.
For all of us here at Maine Public, I'm Jennifer Rooks.
Thank you so much for joining us.
(audience applauding) (dramatic music)
Support for PBS provided by:
Maine Public Original Productions is a local public television program presented by Maine PBS













