
Visualizing Herd Immunity
Season 8 Episode 27 | 14m 49sVideo has Audio Description, Closed Captions
We use lots and lots of mousetraps and ping-pong balls to show how this works.
Since the start of the coronavirus COVID-19 pandemic, the term “herd immunity” has been all over the news. But what does it really mean? One thing most people don’t realize about vaccines is that they aren’t just to protect the person who gets the shot. They also protect the population as a whole, even people who didn’t get the shot. We use mousetraps & ping-pong balls to show you how that works.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

Visualizing Herd Immunity
Season 8 Episode 27 | 14m 49sVideo has Audio Description, Closed Captions
Since the start of the coronavirus COVID-19 pandemic, the term “herd immunity” has been all over the news. But what does it really mean? One thing most people don’t realize about vaccines is that they aren’t just to protect the person who gets the shot. They also protect the population as a whole, even people who didn’t get the shot. We use mousetraps & ping-pong balls to show you how that works.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Be Smart
Be Smart is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipHey smart people, Joe here.
And this is 500 mousetraps and 500 ping-pong balls.
And this is a Slow Mo Guy.
Hello.
(Joe) Today, we are going to set all of these off.
But why, Joe?
Because it's going to look awesome... And to show you why vaccines work, not just by protecting you, but also how they can protect a whole population.
And I'm going to do that with this.
[DRAMATIC MUSIC PLAYING] [THEME MUSIC PLAYING] I got a flu shot this year, and that means I'm essentially immune to this particular strain of the flu virus.
My immune system is like, "I've seen you before.
You're not welcome here."
And so I'll never really get sick with that particular strain of flu.
[BLOWS] Wow.
I've got a lot of work to do.
That's one goal of vaccines-- to protect individuals from getting sick.
And they do that really well.
But there's an even bigger goal that most people don't think about-- getting enough people in a population immune to a disease so that the whole group ends up protected-- even people who didn't get the vaccine.
How does that work exactly?
It's a concept called herd immunity.
Since the start of the coronavirus pandemic, the term "herd immunity" has been all over the news.
Herd immunity is an idea that goes back at least 100 years.
From what we know, veterinarians coined the term in the early 20th century when talking about protecting actual herds from disease.
And later, scientists started applying the idea to human diseases.
When people talk about herd immunity today, what they really mean is an idea that scientists call "herd threshold."
In other words, we need some key percentage of the population immune to a germ to stop disease transmission.
And that threshold is different for every germ.
Let's say a germ lands here and none of these people are immune.
Suppose one person can give that germ to four others on average.
That germ has a basic reproduction number of four, which we write as an R with a little sub-zero.
And you can see that this infection gets out of control really fast.
And we can show how infections spread on a larger scale using 1,000 mousetraps and ping-pong balls.
Ah!
At least that's what we thought we'd have.
But it turns out that setting up 1,000 mousetraps and 1,000 ping-pong balls turned out to be kind of impossible.
So I was going to the bathroom, and I heard the worst sound I've ever heard in my life-- 500 mousetraps being triggered before we were done setting them up.
This is character building.
(announcer) Round two--fight.
(Joe) Why are we still here?
[DRAMATIC MUSIC] Just to suffer?
This is the third time we've done this.
I'm not going to explain why.
(Joe) OK, so after some minor adjustments and recalculations, we can now show how infections spread on a larger scale using 500 mousetraps.
And since this whole thing takes like two seconds to happen, we brought in Gavin from the Slow Mo Guys to shoot in super slow motion at 1,000 frames per second.
Plus, he knows a thing or two about mousetraps.
(Gavin) Three, two, one.
I think it worked.
Oh boy.
God.
[LAUGHS] (Gavin) OK, so we shot that in 4K-- 1,000 frames a second.
It was quite a slow start.
(Joe) It was.
I thought it wasn't going to work.
(Gavin) See, that one sent into the middle.
(Joe) Oh, that's amazing.
This is exactly how a pandemic works.
(Gavin) Looks like you've got two outbreaks at the moment.
(Joe) Oh, there they go.
(Gavin) Yeah, here it's going.
(Joe) It's amazing.
(Gavin) Look at you in the background.
(Joe) I didn't want to get a mousetrap to the eye.
I'm not sure we're insured for that.
This is currently where we are in the pandemic.
(Gavin) I think that one is me there, hiding at home.
This shows it perfectly-- exactly how fast a pandemic can break out.
It took a little longer in real life than three seconds, but it got bad.
Um, I'd say that worked.
Except if this is a pandemic, I guess that's not a good thing.
Great demonstration, though.
And this guy is happy as Larry.
Look, he's still fine.
He's good.
Way to stay home, bud.
So how do you keep a pandemic from growing?
Well, you have to give people immunity without them getting sick.
And how do you do that?
Vaccines.
That's what vaccines are for.
(Joe) Let's go back to this example.
To keep the number of infected people from growing, you need each sick person to give the germ to one or fewer people.
That would mean if an infected person sneezes on four people, at least three of those people are immune.
The germ has a low probability of ever encountering someone it can infect.
So eventually, the whole group ends up protected.
Now, let's see this version in action, but with our mousetraps.
(Gavin) So now all of these white balls are sat on inactive mousetraps.
That's right--those basically represent people who have gotten the vaccine, so they can't explode their coronavirus all over the rest of the table.
And hopefully when we throw this in there, it'll look a little bit different than the last one.
Three, two, one.
Interestingly, we still had a couple little hot spots, but the herd was immune.
OK, playing back now.
(Joe) OK, we get a little bit.
(Gavin) A couple there.
(Joe) It's like a bad family party.
(Gavin) See, that one landed on all the white balls.
(Joe) And then we get maybe one more.
It's perfect, though.
It's like, those are like a buffer for all the other ones.
(Gavin) What about three or four?
(Joe) That makes sense, because vaccines may not work 100% of the time.
But they can protect the entire population even though this is a lot less interesting than the first version.
Yeah, the more boring this footage gets, the better we're proving the point of the vaccine.
Right.
Maybe even more boring this footage gets, the more normal life can be.
I miss boring.
I miss boring.
Me too.
As you just saw, it's clear that by immunizing enough people or mousetraps, we stopped the chain reaction of infection, and we protected the whole population.
But I want to dig a little deeper, because the science gets really interesting, and I know you guys like to nerd out as much as I do.
To reach herd immunity in the mousetrap example, our threshold was this.
But different germs have different herd immunity thresholds depending on how contagious they are.
For, say, measles, it's super contagious.
One infected person can infect 12 to 18 other people.
So you need 94% of the herd immune to stop the spread.
Polio is seven, so the threshold is 85% immune.
These thresholds are where we get our goals for mass vaccination programs.
There's a pretty simple bit of math to figure out the minimum proportion of a population that has to be immunized to stop an infection with a given reproduction number.
And graphed out, it looks like this.
So what's the R-naught for the virus that causes COVID-19?
This is one thing that scientists are still trying to figure out for certain, but it's likely somewhere in here.
That means to keep infections from growing, this percentage of the population needs to be immune.
And if the virus mutates to become more contagious, you can see that the percent of the population that's immune would need to be even higher.
The fastest, safest way to reach that level of immunity is with vaccines.
Vaccines currently prevent two to three million deaths every year from diseases like diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, influenza, and measles.
They're basically the best public health tool since toilets and clean water.
Now, does everyone who gets the vaccine become immune?
No, but an effective vaccine works in most people.
For instance, the measles vaccine-- that works in about 97% of people.
For the COVID-19 vaccines, the data tells us they protect more than 90% of the people who get the shot, or shots, since many of them work best with two doses.
And that 90-plus percent is good news, because it's almost impossible to make sure absolutely every person gets a vaccine.
Say that 60% of people get a vaccine that's effective 90% of the time.
Well, that's only 54% effective protection, which is below the threshold our math tells us we need for COVID.
But for a vaccine that's 90% effective, if 75% of people get it, then we're above the threshold.
In the end, the important thing is to get enough people vaccinated based on how effective a given vaccine is.
In the real world, disease outbreaks are a bit more complicated than mousetraps or simple graphs.
But this model explains what health officials try to do.
We have a group of susceptible people here.
Some of them get infected and go here.
And from there, they either recover here or they die.
To control a germ, the goal is to get enough people here and fewer people here so that the germ has no susceptible people left to infect.
Some people argue we should get people into the immune bucket by just letting them get infected and then recover, like a big global chicken pox party for COVID-19.
But without a vaccine, if the only pathway to this recovered group is to get infected, that means some number of people are going to end up here-- dead.
What a vaccine does is lets you jump straight from here to here and avoid here.
And if we have a choice that lets us avoid death, why wouldn't we take it?
We know this has worked before with diseases like measles, mumps, rubella, chicken pox, and polio.
They usually flare up in cycles, because as more people got infected and recovered, the disease would slow down until new babies were born, letting the virus find a new susceptible population, and a new outbreak would happen.
Vaccines helped disrupt these cycles by keeping the susceptible population low for longer periods of time.
And in some cases, vaccines can disrupt the cycle so much, they can completely eradicate the germs from the planet.
This has happened twice-- one time with a human disease, smallpox, and another time with an animal disease, rinderpest.
And there are efforts ongoing now to use vaccines to eradicate polio.
I mean, in fact, vaccines work so well they have a funny way of fooling people into thinking that they don't need them anymore.
Over the past several years, measles vaccination rates have stalled out around 85%.
That's 10% less than we need to keep outbreaks of this super infectious disease at bay.
We're starting to see the effects.
Last year, a whopping 870,000 measles cases were reported, and measles deaths hit a 23-year high.
At least half the countries that suspended measles vaccination campaigns because of the COVID-19 pandemic have reported new outbreaks.
The point is, we have to stay vigilant.
Vaccines are critical to ending a pandemic like COVID-19, but it won't happen overnight.
I mean, a raging forest fire doesn't stop the moment people start spraying water on it, and neither does a pandemic just because a vaccine is available.
In today's society, one infected person can move across the world to a susceptible community really quickly.
And one little spark has the potential to start a new fire.
One of the biggest challenges facing public health officials is making sure that different communities in different parts of the world have access to vaccines, making enough of them, making them affordable, and making sure people understand why they're important.
That gets us back to that surprising reason that vaccines are important.
Vaccines aren't just for you.
They're for you and everyone else.
When vaccines for these germs first came out, infections also went down in older populations that didn't actually get immunized.
We know this works, and it can work again with everyone's help.
Every vaccine that's given has the potential to protect more than one person.
And that's a beautiful way to end a disease, if you ask me.
One more thing--it's important to remember that how bad a germ is has a lot to do with us.
I mean, diseases aren't just something that happens to us.
Their infectiveness isn't set in stone.
And our behavior can play a big part in keeping us safe.
Things like masks, social distancing, hygiene--they still matter alongside vaccines, and that looks like this.
What--what are you doing?
Oh, I wanted to put us in there, so I'm just drawing us.
This is you.
(Joe) My head's not nearly that round.
I also couldn't remember what the nose and mouth look like, so I just drew the mask.
There are no noses and mouths.
Let's do this.
It might be the worst thing I've ever shot.
This is 5,000 pictures of basically nothing happening.
(Joe) I would kill for that right now.
Vaccines are the greatest boring thing ever.
Maybe something happened and we just didn't see it with our human eye.
-Yeah.
-Nope.
Nope, there's nothing.
Maybe we should just delete this.
It's a 64 gig file, so-- Wow.
All those ones and zeros wasted.
(Joe) Vaccines combined with the right behavior-- it's a super-powered combination.
Let's go home, me.
Stay curious.
- Science and Nature
A series about fails in history that have resulted in major discoveries and inventions.
Support for PBS provided by: