Virgin of Guadalupe

 

*CORRECTION: Several viewers pointed out that in this story we said Catholics “worship” Mary. The word should have been “venerate,” and we thank you for reminding us of that.

BOB ABERNETHY: Every December 12, U.S. cities with large Mexican or Central American populations are the sites of colorful celebrations honoring the Virgin of Guadalupe. These public devotions to the mother of Jesus may seem like cultural curiosities today, but before long, celebrations such as this may be common all over the country — because one American Catholic in three is Hispanic.

Ruben Martinez reports from Los Angeles, where Hispanics make up almost two-thirds of the Catholic population:

RUBEN MARTINEZ: In a country where devotion conjures images of prayer indoors, at home, or at church, Latino Catholics in ever-increasing numbers celebrate the feast day of the Virgin of Guadalupe in massive public demonstrations of adoration. While impressive, the observances that take place in California and the American Southwest on this day pale in comparison to the huge celebration in Mexico City, which can draw as many as five million worshippers.

The celebration is rooted in a Mexican story nearly 5,000 years old. According to tradition, the olive-skinned virgin appeared before the Aztec Indian Juan Diego in 1531. It was a few short years after the Spanish conquest, a time of untold misery for the decimated Indian population.

Mr. LUIS LEON (Arizona State University): One of the first things she told him was, rhetorically she asked, “Am I not here? Who is your mother? Am I not here to help you? I’ve come to help the Indians.” And you have to remember that at the time of the apparition, 1531, the Aztec capital had just been conquered 10 years earlier, so Indians were literally dying by the millions. And Guadalupe’s apparition healed those wounds.

MARTINEZ: Diego asked the virgin for a sign that would serve as proof of her appearance. With winter approaching, she is believed to have showered him with dozens of red roses, and her image was emblazoned upon his cloak.

Devotion to the virgin is more than just a mere affirmation of faith. It is also a way for Mexicans and Latin Americans to give flesh and spirit to their mixed European and Indian identity. And in this era of migration, the virgin also crosses borders.

Tens of thousands made the pilgrimage to Our Lady Queen of Angels Church, better known as La Placita, the original pueblo church of Los Angeles, which features a huge outdoor altar to her.

Father ALBERTO VASQUEZ: You know, when our blessed lady appeared to Juan Diego, the very first thing he heard was music, and that’s very important to our — for our culture, music, flowers. So music being such an important thing for us, it’s — just has to be that way that we’re going to salute somebody we love with music.

MARTINEZ: The numbers of virgin devotees have increased sharply in recent years with the massive influx of immigrants from Mexico and Central America. In Los Angeles alone, the day before the feast day, some 50,000 people came to the old Olympic Coliseum to worship* the lady whom they call the Empress of the Americas. For 19 years, Maria Aguilar has been a member of the Guadalupe Devotional Group. This year she led the rosary at the coliseum.

Ms. MARIA AGUILAR: This was very, very unique and very special because we had so many people praying to our blessed mother in their own language. It was beautiful.

MARTINEZ: Among the many rituals of the feast day is a pilgrimage to a place of worship. In Los Angeles, they come from all over the city. In the wee hours at La Placita, faithful sing the “Mananitas,” a traditional Latin American birthday song.

Ms. MARTHA SANCHEZ (Through Translator): Wherever we are in the world, wherever there are Latinos, the virgin is there for us.

Mr. ERNESTO REYES: We know that we have hope in life when we think about her and everything.

Ms. LEONARDA SOTOMAYOR (Through Translator): The faith is strong in Mexico, the love people have for the virgin, but you feel it more here because we are far from our homeland.

Mr. LEON: The immigrant experience, whenever a person is coming, is one of tremendous disorientation and loneliness and fear. It’s a very frightening experience, entering into an unknown land. Guadalupe adds solace and comfort, just like she did in the beginning to the Indian Juan Diego. She protected him. She was going to comfort him. She does the same to immigrants.

MARTINEZ: Much of the mystical experience of Guadalupe takes place in public. She is represented in hundreds of murals on the streets of cities throughout the Southwest and increasingly in parts of the Midwest.

Ms. AGUILAR: As you walk in East L.A., what do you see on the streets, on the murals, on the cars? It’s our Lady of Guadalupe. And sometimes, you know, you say, “My gosh, what is it about this blessed mother? We don’t see any pictures of Jesus anywhere. We don’t see any crosses; maybe one or two crosses along the way. But you see her everywhere.”

MARTINEZ: Eva Rivera owns a furniture store in South Central Los Angeles. She commissioned a mural of the virgin for her business.

Ms. EVA RIVERA (Through Translator): I got the idea because people would constantly graffiti my walls, and I don’t know, thank God, ever since I had the mural made, everything has changed.

MARTINEZ: Even religious symbols are vulnerable. Vandals recently defaced Rivera’s mural and dozens of others in Los Angeles, prompting an outcry from virgin devotees.

Ms. RIVERA (Through Translator): It made me very mad to see that, and I said, “What kind of people would do such a thing?” Then I looked for someone to restore it.

MARTINEZ: For many devotees, whether one, two, or more generations removed from the old country, the virgin seems to offer hope, no matter where they are on their journey from country to country or language to language. With the numbers of Latino Catholics steadily increasing in the U.S., the virgin’s feast and other Old World traditions will likely be more and more visible in the American religious landscape in years to come. Indeed, the virgin’s hold on her flock appears to be even more powerful on this side of the border, where the immigrants, it seems, need her more than ever.

For Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly, this is Ruben Martinez in Los Angeles.

Ethics of Organ Donations

To keep up with the skyrocketing demand for life-saving organ donations, Pennsylvania officials are trying an innovative and controversial program to offer financial incentives to organ donors. But it has already raised several ethical concerns about what could happen once money is attached to something that’s always been an altruistic act.

Labyrinth

 

MARY ALICE WILLIAMS: Both were forms of medieval meditation, but with opposite intents. A maze, with its blind alleys and dead ends, is meant to confound. A labyrinth offers one direction, one path that leads you to the center. That ancient construct has some very modern advocates, and they’re not just religious. Ruben Martinez reports from San Francisco.

RUBEN MARTINEZ: Walking a series of concentric circles may seem like a curious ritual, but for some, it can be a profound spiritual experience.

Reverend LAUREN ARTRESS (Grace Cathedral): It becomes a matter of trusting the path and surrendering to it; walking the pattern that symbolically takes you to center also experientially takes you to your center.

MARTINEZ: It was 10 years ago that the Reverend Lauren Artress discovered the labyrinth as a form of walking meditation, a spiritual practice that quiets the mind and awakens the imagination. As canon pastor at San Francisco’s Grace Cathedral and also a practicing psychotherapist, Artress had been searching for tools that would satisfy what she sees as the great spiritual quest of millennial America.

Reverend Lauren Artress, Grace CathedralRev. ARTRESS: We think our way of — to the mystery or to God or the divine one is through thinking, and that’s not true. It’s through experiencing. And the labyrinth is a perfect container for ourselves. When you walk into the labyrinth, it really becomes a reflection or a mirror of the soul. You can see that part of yourself that really works against yourself. You can see your critical inner voice against yourself and against others. Anything that stops you from connecting to the divine, it has to come to the surface and release, and that’s what happens in the labyrinth.

MARTINEZ: Before bringing a labyrinth to her own church, Artress had journeyed to Chartres Cathedral in France, where medieval builders had hewn this pre-Christian symbol into the stone wall.

Rev. ARTRESS: It had not been uncovered for several hundred years, and it was quite amazing when you see it.

MARTINEZ: Artress walked the Chartres labyrinth as she believes the medieval pilgrims had done, perhaps as a substitute for a journey to the Holy Land. As a result of her efforts, the Chartres labyrinth has now been opened for modern-day pilgrims to walk the ancient path.

Five years ago, at the urging of Lauren Artress, San Francisco’s Grace Cathedral began a trend by installing a labyrinth modeled precisely after the one in Chartres. There’s now a network of churches across the country using labyrinths, encouraged and supported by the worldwide project Artress heads.

Rev. ARTRESS: How many of you are able to have a labyrinth in your life?

MARTINEZ: Artress teaches the labyrinth as a ritual without formulas or dogma. She calls it a process that crosses denominations and faiths.

Rev. ARTRESS: This is part of what’s being redefined again for us, as we begin to search and realize that we are spiritually hungry and that most of our traditions that we have aren’t addressing that hunger.

MARTINEZ: Secular institutions have also discovered labyrinths as a meditation tool. The California Pacific Medical Center in San Francisco was the first hospital to install a labyrinth to support staff and patients.

Ms. NANCY HOPSON: Soon after my diagnosis with breast cancer, I was just agonizing over a decision. I walked the labyrinth, and by the time I got to the middle, I realized that it was all going to be okay one way or another, and there might be something to learn — be learned from this experience.

MARTINEZ: The labyrinth experience is as varied as the individuals who walk its paths. It is a place where people can mix Christian mysticism with psychology or Buddhism with self-help.

And how would you respond to a skeptic who would say that you are basically going out of bounds, outside the religious institution?

Rev. ARTRESS: It’s never outside the tradition, because the labyrinth is a path of prayer. And the more ways we can help people pray and meditate and quiet the mind, the better off everybody is.

MARTINEZ: The labyrinth may go the way of temporary spiritual fads, but right now it’s a clear sign that Americans are still looking for answers and new rituals and practices.

Rev. ARTRESS: We’re in such a — profoundly, deeply changing times that we don’t know what end is up. So find something to focus you; find something that embodies you; find a path that keeps you prayerful, thoughtful, open, and moving with the flow. And I think that’s what the labyrinth does.

MARTINEZ: For Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly, I’m Ruben Martinez in San Francisco.

Gargoyles

 

KIM LAWTON: They loom off the world’s great cathedrals, mystical, sometimes menacing, always mysterious. In the 12th century, St. Bernard of Clarevoe wrote, “What is that ridiculous monstrosity doing? An amazing kind of deformed beauty, and yet a beautiful deformity. What are the filthy apes doing there, the creatures, part man and part beast?” Today, the same questions could be asked. What are gargoyles doing, not just on cathedrals, but in front yards, gift shops, publishing houses, and all over the Internet?

Ms. PHYLLIS TICKLE (Publishers Weekly): They’re everywhere. They’re ubiquitous. So I think we can say that they’re perhaps as popular a religious object right now as we’ve got in the general culture, that is, in the nondevout culture.

LAWTON: The English word “gargoyle” comes from the French “gargouille,” meaning throat or pipe. The name hints at the very functional reason for the gargoyle and for his brother, the grotesque, which are often confused for each other.

Unidentified Woman: To be an official gargoyle, what this guy’s got, you’ve got to have an opening, a hole going through you, okay? So the water can go through the gargoyle, just like a drainpipe. They are part of our gutter system. What about grotesques? They have a job, too, but they don’t have holes going through them. They have no opening, no pipe going through them. The water rolls over the top of them, okay? Doesn’t go through them.

post02-gargoylesLAWTON: Such a drainage system helps protects cathedrals from water stains and erosion. But over the centuries other, more mystical traditions also developed. Many considered gargoyles the spiritual protectors of churches as well, scaring off demons and evil spirits. Some historians believe gargoyles were inspired from pagan eras and were used to make churches feel more familiar to new Christians. Others said gargoyles were morality lessons in stone, reminding people that while purity and good may be found inside the church, sin and evil are never far away.

Mr. VINCE PALUMBO (Master Carver): See, you’ve got the facial …

LAWTON: It’s got the spout, it’s got the water spout.

Vince Palumbo is a fifth-generation stone carver, one of a vanishing breed of artists. He’s worked at Washington’s National Cathedral for nearly 40 years …

Mr. PALUMBO: If you bend down here, you’ll see another one.

LAWTON: … carving saints and gargoyles. Columbo says in more modern times, there’ve been some changes in the tradition of gargoyles.

Mr. PALUMBO: In the older days, a gargoyle was as ugly as possible, you know, because it’s supposed to scare the devil away from the house of the Lord, you know.

post03-gargoylesLAWTON: But, Palumbo says, perhaps as modern people became more rational, gargoyles became more whimsical, often caricatures of real people rather than scary demon chasers. He’s not pleased about that change.

Mr. PALUMBO: I mean, contemporarily artistically speaking, they look good, but they’re not the gargoyle that to — I mean, who’s going to — the rabbit, who wants to scare — you know, who gets scared from the rabbit? You see what I mean?

LAWTON: American pop culture is rediscovering gargoyles, both their whimsical and their menacing sides. There are several new books out about gargoyles, from children’s books to architectural studies to gift books. There are dozens of Web sites about gargoyles, from the scholarly to the offbeat. And gargoyles are rivaling angels as a hot collectible. This store in Boston specializes in the sale of gargoyles and grotesques. Shop co-owner Louis Gordon says his customers are fascinated by gargoyles’ relationship to the divine.

Mr. LOUIS GORDON (Gargoyles, Grotesques & Chimeras Shop): So much religion is only emphasizing the good or the beautiful, where some people are attracted to the more profane or the scary. The gargoyles bring you in and all of a sudden you become introduced to the sacred side of yourself. And the gargoyles are sort of the guardians to that entrance.

LAWTON: Culture critic Phyllis Tickle believes the interest in gargoyles is not only fun but also reflects some important trends in contemporary spirituality.

Ms. TICKLE: Much of the spiritual hunger that’s going on in this country right now has a kind of medieval flavor to it.

LAWTON: Gargoyles, she says, symbolize an acknowledgment that evil does exist. And she believes for many modern people, gargoyles fulfill a deep interest in the spiritual unknown in a world that’s not easily understood or explained.

Ms. TICKLE: They play with the idea that just beyond the regular, just beyond the expected, just beyond the realm, there hovers the world of the other. And the gargoyle said, “Aha, look at me. I’m the other. And I won’t hurt you, but I will scare you just a little bit. I will remind you that in the world of God, not everything is as everything seems.”

LAWTON: I’m Kim Lawton reporting.

Theodore Hesburgh

Hesburgh was president of Notre Dame from 1952 to 1987. He helped transform Notre Dame into a premier academic institution. He is considered one of the most influential Catholic leaders of the past century, widely respected by those inside and outside the church.

The Legacy of C.S. Lewis

BOB ABERNETHY: November 29 marks the 100th anniversary of the birth of the late C. S. Lewis, one of the most influential and beloved Christian writers in this century. Lewis, who was British, wrote 38 books, from the best-selling children’s book The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe to Mere Christianity, one of the most widely read explanations of the Christian faith. Our critic, Martha Bayles, recently traveled to England to examine Lewis’s legacy.

MARTHA BAYLES: I am one of 800 Americans who have come to Oxford, England to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the birth of its famous former resident, the writer C. S. Lewis.

Unidentified Man #1: Well, I flew all the way from Honolulu to be here in England, and the reason is because when I became a Christian at the age of 15, never having gone to church before then, C. S. Lewis became my early mentor, and reading so many of his books really was a foundation of my Christian faith.

BAYLES: Lewis is renowned for his children’s stories, The Chronicles of Narnia, and for his literary scholarship done here at Oxford’s venerable Magdalen College. But those works are eclipsed by his Christian apologetics, a series of short books that are eloquent, lucid, emotionally honest, and hugely influential.

A young C. S. LewisBorn a Protestant in Belfast, Northern Ireland, Lewis rejected the religion of his boyhood, which he later called “the dry husks of Christianity,” for its hatred of Catholicism. A brilliant student, he was wounded in World War I and returned to Oxford an agnostic.

C. S. Lewis loved a good argument, and he had a lot of them. One of the most famous took place here on Addison’s Walk at Magdalen College. It was after that argument that Lewis became a believing Christian.

Lewis began the evening talking about myth with two friends, one of them J.R.R. Tolkien, author of Lord of the Rings. They argued for hours about whether some myths were true. And back in his room at 3 a.m., Lewis wrote to another friend, “I have just passed from believing in God to definitely believing in Christ.” He joined the Church of England and for years attended services here at Holy Trinity in the village of Headington Quarry. But Lewis did not just write for his fellow Anglicans; his message crossed national and denominational borders.

Prof. Thomas HowardThomas Howard, professor of English at St. John’s College in Massachusetts, explains Lewis’s American appeal.

Professor THOMAS HOWARD (St. John’s College, Massachusetts): Yes, I think it started with Lewis’s book Mere Christianity, in the earlyish-to-middish forties, and the evangelicals who had been typecast by Hollywood, the stage, novelists, everybody else as sort of Appalachian ignoramuses found an articulate, incandescent intellect.

BAYLES: A key destination for Americans is Lewis’s home, called The Kilns because it was originally a brick works. Stanley Mattson is the director of the C. S. Lewis Foundation, which organized this festival and has run a tremendous volunteer effort to restore The Kilns.

Stanley MattsonMr. STANLEY MATTSON (Director, C. S. Lewis Foundation): This was a home that was, literally, choking with weed grass. The windows—we found vines coming through the windows at six, eight feet into this very room, and it was very sad to see it.

BAYLES: George Sayer, a student and close friend who has written a Lewis biography, is not sure Lewis would approve.

Mr. GEORGE SAYER (Friend of C.S. Lewis): He’d have been embarrassed and thought quite incorrect the interest in the personality of the man.

BAYLES: Douglas Gresham is the son of Joy Gresham, an American who married Lewis in 1957 and died three years later. Their story was made into a film called “Shadowlands.” Douglas recalls how his stepfather felt about fame.

Mr. DOUGLAS GRESHAM (Stepson of C.S. Lewis): I can remember he and my mother used to tease each other about it occasionally at the dinner table, for example, when he would receive some letter from—a letter of adulation from a fan, and he would read it out at the table with a great grin on his face, and my mother would chide him gently.

BAYLES: Does this mean we should ignore the trappings and details of Lewis’s life?

Mr. MATTSON: When we fail to honor people and one another, we really, I think, become impoverished as a people, so I think remembering is very important business.

BAYLES: Christianity for Lewis was not a feel-good religion. Yes, he says, we should love other people, but that’s not the end of the story.

Gilbert Meilaender teaches Christian ethics at Valparaiso University.

Professor GILBERT MEILAENDER (Valparaiso University): Lewis has an extremely strong sense of the importance of close ties in life, how it’s impossible to live fully without them, but how much pain they bring and particularly how much pain they bring when one is drawn away from them toward God.

Unidentified Man #2: C. S. Lewis dealt with pain and struggled with pain, and my motivation in coming is to try and make sense of life and pain.

Unidentified Woman: And I think that we’re here to use him in a sense as an icon—in the true sense of the word “icon” in that you look through the image to something further, which is God.

BAYLES: I’m Martha Bayles for Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly in Oxford, England.

Choir sings hymn.

Billy Graham

 

BOB ABERNETHY: And finally, evangelist Billy Graham celebrates his 80th birthday on November 7th. Graham declined suggestions for a big party, saying the birthday he really wants to celebrate will be his 100th. While most 80-year-olds have long retired from their chosen line of work, Graham continues with his ministry. But as Kim Lawton reports, his organization is thinking about the future.

KIM LAWTON: He’s preached the gospel to more live audiences than anyone in history, more than 210 million people in 185 countries.

Dr. BILLY GRAHAM (Excerpt From Previous Crusade): I want to know I’m going to heaven. I want Christ in my heart. I want to know I’m saved and I’m ready to meet God.

A younger Billy GrahamLAWTON: He’s participated in every presidential inauguration since Lyndon B. Johnson. And he’s been a friend and counselor to numerous presidents, including a special relationship with Richard Nixon. Arguably, he’s one of the most influential men of the 20th century. But as Billy Graham turns 80, there’s a new poignancy as well: the progression of age and Parkinson’s disease, faltering steps and awkward movements, often aided now by a cane.

Professor RANDALL BALMER (Columbia University): Age is certainly catching up to him and we’re facing now, I think, the end of an era.

LAWTON: Graham’s ministry is slowing down, but he says he has no intention of retiring until God retires him. Just two weeks ago, he held a crusade in Tampa. It was a vintage Graham crusade, complete with high-powered guests, and the evangelist showed he’s keeping up with the times; the crusade, including an appearance by the chart-topping rock group Jars of Clay, was broadcast live on the Internet.

Christian band Jars of Clay at Billy Graham crusadeBilly Graham can still pack stadiums like this one, but many wonder whether mass evangelism is viable after him. At a time when people seem to be seeking more individualized spirituality, is the age of stadium crusades coming to an end?

Dr. JOHN R. CORTS (Billy Graham Evangelical Association): Sure it is, in one sense of the word. That is, it’s coming to the end as far as Billy Graham is concerned. He’s 80 years of age, and obviously, he can’t keep going for another 50 years. But I would say that as far as mass events are concerned, that has been there throughout history, all the way back to the time of Christ when there were great multitudes of people, and they’re still there.

Prof. BALMER: And I think they will remain so as long as sporting events are popular. People like big events. People like the feeling of being in a crowd where something really exciting is going on.

LAWTON: But the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, the Minneapolis-based ministry Graham founded in 1950, is preparing for the inevitable. Franklin Graham, who conducts his own crusades and heads a Christian relief group, will eventually succeed his father as chief executive officer.

Billy Graham with son FranklinDr. CORTS: Now Franklin will have organizational responsibilities to continue or to lead the organization in whatever direction it should go. What the ministry direction is going is something born of God and something we can’t really predict or even try to manipulate.

Prof. BALMER: If he tries to follow his father’s program in a kind of lockstep sort of way, he’s going to be disappointed and probably will fail, which is no judgment against him. It’s just that Billy Graham has been such a pioneer and such an important and charismatic and much-loved figure in America and throughout the world.

LAWTON: The BGEA oversees many projects, including crusades for several evangelists, but much of the work has been focused on Billy Graham, and ministry officials acknowledge the organization may not go on forever.

Dr. CORTS: We’re here to serve God’s people, and our hope for the future, both that of Mr. Graham or Franklin Graham, the board of directors, and everyone that works here, is that God will show us what his direction for the future is, and we’d like to be responsive to it.

Dr. GRAHAM (Excerpt From Previous Crusade): You come, young, old, whoever you are.

LAWTON: For now, Graham has announced crusades next year in Indianapolis and St. Louis. And in the year 2000, he’s planning a huge conference in Amsterdam for worldwide itinerant evangelists. But, he says, his future is ultimately in God’s hands.

Dr. GRAHAM (Excerpt From Previous Crusade): I know I’m going to heaven. Why? Because of what Christ did on the cross and what he did by being raised from the dead.

LAWTON: I’m Kim Lawton, RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY.

ABERNETHY: Those close to him say Graham is indeed thinking a lot about heaven these days. He’s writing a book on the subject.