
Extended Interview: Neighborhood as Systems Toolkit
Clip: Season 3 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
An extended version of our interview with researcher and physician Dr. Carley Riley.
Their effort calls it, "a step-by-step guide for organizing neighborhood stakeholders to tackle complex systems problems and create positive impact in your community." It's a free resource already empowering neighbors in Cincinnati to make change; perhaps it could help your area too.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Brick by Brick is a local public television program presented by CET

Extended Interview: Neighborhood as Systems Toolkit
Clip: Season 3 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
Their effort calls it, "a step-by-step guide for organizing neighborhood stakeholders to tackle complex systems problems and create positive impact in your community." It's a free resource already empowering neighbors in Cincinnati to make change; perhaps it could help your area too.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Brick by Brick
Brick by Brick is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Dr.
Carly Riley is a researcher and practicing physician at Cincinnati Children's Hospital who helped design the neighborhood as systems approach.
Dr.
Riley, thank you for being here with - Thank - You very much.
- So let's talk about broken systems in neighborhoods in Cincinnati and Dayton.
You've spent more than a decade researching how to fix these broken systems.
What are the characteristics of them and what are the challenged systems that you're seeing in our area?
- One of the important things that we found over the last 10 years in working deeply within neighborhoods with community members and organizations is that neighborhoods behave as systems.
Housing, safety, food, business, all interact together.
And each neighborhood is comprised of different components working differently and producing different outcomes for the people that live within those neighborhoods.
And so in fact, we say systems aren't broken, we say they're perfectly designed to get the outcomes that they're getting.
And so in neighborhoods where residents aren't experiencing the health and wellbeing outcomes that they would like to be experiencing, then what they need to do is address the system, not fix the symptoms.
Okay.
One of the things that we find here across Cincinnati is that there are neighborhoods that have people living within them that are experiencing wonderful outcomes, wonderful health outcomes, wonderful wellbeing, and then there's other neighborhoods in which people are disproportionately experiencing adverse health outcomes as well as lower wellbeing.
And we can understand that neighborhoods producing different outcomes means that we need to improve the system that is working within the neighborhoods that are not getting the outcomes that we want to see in order for the people living within them to experience better lives.
Can - You tell us a little bit of what are the most challenged systems that you're seeing in these neighborhoods?
- So there's been a really wonderful foundation of study looking at what are the different conditions that people need in order to really achieve their best possible lives, to really thrive.
And one of the places I would look to is the vital conditions for thriving.
And there are seven of them with belonging and civic muscle at the center.
And so in neighborhoods or in communities where people really have a strong sense of belonging and also have the ability to really come together and to use their voice and to improve their own neighborhood of their own actions, those neighborhoods tend to have better outcomes, more people thriving.
We also see that housing as well as food and basic needs for health and safety, along with transportation and lifelong learning, ability to have meaningful work and wealth, those are all really essential conditions as well.
If the people within a neighborhood though have that sense of belonging and ability to really shape and take action to improve their own conditions, then those neighborhoods tend to be seeing better housing, better food, better other vital conditions as well.
So - Residents are looking for solutions to help improve their neighborhoods.
You've created a toolkit, got a lot of tools in there.
What's been most effective?
- So the guide that emerged out of the last 10 years of work really provides a pathway, a simple pathway for residents and other community members to work together in order to improve outcomes within their own neighborhoods.
It's a simple, simple pathway.
Connect, explore, test, sustain.
And this is where people can come together, figure out what are the problems that are priority that they want to address, have a way to find the leverage points to actually make things better, test small solutions and then scale what works.
- Folk Singer and activist Joan Baez had a quote, "Action is the antidote to despair."
You say it's critical that neighbors become active agents in creating system level change.
Why is that?
- We have found that in the work that we're doing that action absolutely is the precursor for hope.
What we have seen in neighborhoods where individuals have a sense of agency and that are able to take action together and then produce change and improvement and results for themselves, that that creates a virtuous cycle in which then people are increasingly more active.
And then that itself is a very hopeful filling activity.
And so what we're striving for is that we can give the tools to neighborhoods for themselves to then enter into their own virtuous cycles in which they continue to be the best at getting better within their own place.
- So tell us some of the neighborhoods that are already using this neighborhood assistance approach and what kind of impact has it had?
- Importantly, this guide and toolkit emerged in working with neighborhoods.
And as much as 10 plus years ago, we began working in neighborhoods such as Avondale and East Price Hill, working really deeply with the community members there to hone this approach and test it and then build these tools.
Now we're leveraging them within the Safe Network, System to Achieve Food Equity Network.
We were just honored with the Impact Award from the city.
And so the work that we're doing there in the neighborhoods of East Price Hill, Lower Price Hill, West End and others are working together with the residents to build neighborhood resource hubs where neighborhoods themselves define the spaces in which people living within that neighborhood can come to for food and connection to other services.
- Can you give an example of kind of a way that the neighborhood has made an improvement or made it better for themselves?
- Sure.
So I'll give an example of Avondale.
We have been working with leaders and residents of Avondale across a number of different priorities that they have.
One is around food security and another is around child abuse and neglect prevention.
In working with these, the neighborhood themselves has been, they created their own solutions.
One of them was to work with Last Mile, which is a few food rescue agency here.
And they together designed the first Last Mile mobile market in which Last Mile would bring food directly into neighborhood spots that the neighborhood themselves designated as the places to go and then created a market in which people from the neighborhood can behave as shoppers and access free foods, including meat and dairy on a regular basis.
They now operate three to four times a week within that neighborhood, all guided by neighborhood residents themselves.
Another is the Avondale Respite Center.
That is a new, a new nonprofit that exists within Avondale to provide crisis nursery support for families within the Avondale neighborhood.
And that idea was born out of women coming together at the local community center and talking about what was needed within the neighborhood in order to support families.
And that is what they've designed and they've now launched it.
It's called ARC.
- That's amazing.
What does it do to those neighborhood and community members once they start seeing that their voice actually is making a difference?
- It begets more ideas and more action.
And importantly, not all action produces impact, right?
And so one of the things that this guide helps people understand is, are the actions that we're taking actually leading to improvement in the outcomes that we care about?
Simply being busy doesn't necessarily mean that we're improving the health and wellbeing of other people.
We have to target the leverage points within the neighborhood as a system in order to really produce meaningful and sustainable outcomes.
- So how do you ensure that residents and families that are helping design, design these systems actually design it and not just become the subjects of these studies?
- Oh, because they're the ones that are utilizing the tools and leading the conversation and ideating and making decisions.
We as a team throughout this whole process have essentially created the context within which people, neighbors use these tools themselves.
And what's wonderful now is that they're freely accessible and people can use them of their own free will.
- And this toolkit is available for anyone, is that correct?
- Neighborhoodtoolkit.org.
- Okay.
So anyone anywhere - - Anybody can go there from anywhere and use the toolkit and guide.
I - Want to ask you, what can doctors, nonprofits, other members of community, including neighbors, do differently to make real change within a city or government policy?
Because they often move really slow.
- One of the things I would encourage that people who are within organizations or systems and who are activated to support real change is for them to come to and show up in neighborhood and to be present and to listen and then to work on ways where they shift the privilege and power that they have to the people who are living within the neighborhoods so that they themselves have what they need to make the decisions for their own selves.
- It's interesting because I often think that a lot of the decision makers often don't, are making decisions but don't always know the lived experience of the people that are living there.
So when you're bringing them together, does it change how they make decisions?
It - Often does.
And I think this is something that we've been learning here in Cincinnati and that people now are doing more and more bringing together the people with lived experience, with the people who have expertise within the system to co-create change.
We just need to see that become the way that it's just done, like the default way, the way of being.
- Talk just a little bit about the wisdom that people have who've lived in the neighborhoods.
- We did this wonderful, I'll say study, but it was really like a labor of love where we walked alongside nearly more than 40 families as they interacted with the systems that they needed to in order to have their needs met.
And we watched what happened as they tried to have their needs met, not so that we could understand the families, but what we were understanding is they were pinging against the systems, social service systems, nonprofit organizations, civic systems.
And what we were able to do was sort of log what happened when the families did this.
And we could then, from a systems perspective, say, "These are all the failures of the systems that we have here."
And then figure out which are the ones that we want to tackle first.
And we've got system partners, organizations that are doing that right alongside with us.
- And how long would something like that have taken had you not used the people who are living there?
Because how difficult - - We wouldn't have known many of the things because the people who are living within the system, right?
Who are doing the good work of a system really can only see their end of any sort of process.
They may not understand or see what is important or being experienced by the people who are actually trying to access their system or utilize the services of their system.
And so it's essential for us to really understand what's working and what's not working for the people with lived experience and lived expertise to be contributing their wisdom.
- Yeah.
It's amazing because you do have, you have limited sight for different things and you have used an example in the toolkit about the elephant and that everybody sees.
And can you just explain briefly the - Elephant?
Oh yeah, this is one of my favorite tools because people understand it and can understand systems so clearly right away.
So if you imagine seven blindfolded people standing around an elephant, not knowing that it's an elephant in front of them, and then having the ability to reach out and touch what's in front of them and have to say what they think it is.
Well, the person that grabs the tusk may say, "Ah, it's a spear."
Where's the person that grabs a tail may say, "Oh, there's a snake."
And they could argue with each other, right?
They could say, "No, it's a spear.
No, it's a snake."
And they wouldn't get anywhere.
They wouldn't appreciate that what they actually have in front of them is an elephant.
And so what's needed is the people that have touches and understanding of different parts of the system have to communicate with each other in order to say, "Well, I feel something that's like a spear over here.
I feel something that's like a snake over here."
And once you get all seven people sharing what their particular perspective is, they could put together, "Oh, this is an elephant."
And the same thing with housing, with food, with neighborhoods is each different actor within that system sees a different part and they all have to communicate to understand what they have in the middle.
- Interesting.
Well, we always like to ask everyone that we interview this question, but what gives you hope that your system can leave to a thriving community and what do you think makes a thriving community?
- I have a tremendous amount of hope because of who I see leaning in to making a better future.
I have the privilege of getting to walk among many different spaces civic spaces, business spaces, nonprofit housing, and then communities themselves.
And there are so many people who are rolling up their sleeves and leaning in to work together to make a better future.
That is hope.
- And what do you think in general makes a thriving community?
- Oh, well, when all of the people who are living within that community have the ability, the promise, the opportunity to reach and live their best lives, that's when we thrive.
- Well, Dr.
Carly Wally, thank you for your time and thank you for joining us here very much.
RISE Northwest expands access to quality housing
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S3 | 10m 43s | Dayton nonprofit seeks to build the city's northwest neighborhoods with quality housing. (10m 43s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S3 | 30s | Promo for Season 3 of Brick by Brick: Solutions for a Thriving Community (30s)
Extended Interview: Neighborhood as Systems Toolkit
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S3 | 14m 7s | An extended version of our interview with researcher and physician Dr. Carley Riley. (14m 7s)
Cincinnati tool to help renters find housing shows promise
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S3 | 1m 16s | A Cincinnati sponsored website that aids renters had a housing fair at Washington Park. (1m 16s)
Joseph House: Giving Homeless Veterans a Fighting Chance
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S3 Ep5 | 5m 17s | A resource center for veterans in Cincinnati helps them secure housing and employment. (5m 17s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S3 Ep3 | 30s | Solutions to Sustain Neighborhoods. (30s)
Safe Sleep Lot Program helps families navigate homelessness
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S3 Ep1 | 9m 7s | Project Connect helps unhoused families find a safe place to park their cars at night. (9m 7s)
Promo: Brick by Brick - Helping Unhoused Students
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S3 Ep1 | 30s | Promo for Brick by Brick Ep. 301: Safe sleep lots, neighborhoods as systems, and housing. (30s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
Brick by Brick is a local public television program presented by CET







