FRONTLINE/World [home]

Search FRONTLINE/World

FRONTLINE/World Dispatches





Editors' Notes

Pakistan Blog



recent posts

Haiti Quake: Keeping Haiti's Internet Alive

Haiti Quake: Improvisation Amid the Chaos

Bolivia: Back on the Road With Evo

Reflections: The End of a Divided Germany

Peru: Kiva's Web-based Microfinance Growing Up

Honduras: Standoff at the Embassy

China: Wall Scholar

Afghanistan: A Stolen Election?

Swaziland: The King and the Web

Jailed In Iran, A Reporter's Story



January 2010

December 2009

November 2009

October 2009

September 2009

August 2009

July 2009

June 2009

May 2009

April 2009

March 2009

February 2009

January 2009

December 2008

November 2008

October 2008

September 2008

August 2008

July 2008

June 2008

May 2008

April 2008

March 2008

February 2008

January 2008

December 2007

November 2007

October 2007

September 2007

August 2007

July 2007

June 2007

May 2007

April 2007

March 2007

February 2007

January 2007

December 2006

November 2006

October 2006

September 2006

August 2006

July 2006

June 2006

May 2006

April 2006

March 2006

February 2006

January 2006

December 2005

November 2005

October 2005

September 2005

August 2005

July 2005

June 2005

May 2005


RSS Feeds

In Lebanon, Bafflement Turns to Anger and Despair

Coffin is carried into a large burial trench.

Lebanese civil defense workers in the southern city of Tyre carry a coffin into a mass grave prepared for victims of the shelling.

It feels like we're teetering on the brink of collapse here in Beirut. The south is already a complete disaster zone, like something out of a Mad Max movie. Whole villages are destroyed. Donkeys and horses wander aimlessly through the rubble where bodies still rot, trapped under collapsed homes.

Beirut has managed to maintain an air of semi-normalcy until recently. I can still get fresh bagels at Bread Republic, an upscale bakery near my apartment, and a good margarita at a local bar, Dragonfly. My neighborhood bodega opens at 7 a.m. every day, like it always has, although the fresh produce is limited. And Georgette, the local seamstress, still sits in her storefront window hemming pants and skirts.

But all of that feels like it's going to change very soon. Lebanon's health minister warned today that most hospitals in Beirut would start closing down in the next three days. They'll be forced to discharge patients, including the war wounded. There's almost no fuel left in the country to run surgical wards, incubators, and refrigerators for medicine. Nor is there much gasoline to run cars or generators. The gas lines are growing and the prices are rising. Israel has imposed a full blockade on Lebanon and the two fuel tankers, waiting in Cyprus to unload their precious cargo, are too afraid to dock.

Lebanon's health minister warned today that most hospitals in Beirut would start closing down in the next three days. They'll be forced to discharge patients, including the war wounded.

I keep wondering when the 12 hours of electricity I now get from the state will peter out and when exactly the neighborhood generator I'm hooked up to will run dry. In fact as I write, the lights have gone out. My neighborhood generator has not started up. I've been sitting here for two hours in the dark and my refrigerator is already starting to smell.

And yet, I'm still one of the lucky ones. My main challenges are pretty minor in comparison to the hundreds of thousands of Lebanese civilians who have been displaced by this war. At least I'm not living in an airless underground supermarket parking lot, with 2,000 other people, like the one I visited recently. At least I'm still in my apartment, where my major concern, apart from electricity, is fighting cockroaches the size of small mice. Most of Lebanon's garbage men -- from Sri Lanka and India -- fled the country about a week after the conflict started, leaving the garbage to pile up on the streets, creating a small feast for roaches and vermin.

My other immediate concern is just getting enough sleep. The Israelis continue to bomb Beirut's southern suburbs, a few miles from my house, between 3 a.m. and 6 a.m. I now sleep through the 3 a.m. bombings, but the dawn attacks pretty much kill a decent night's rest. At least it hasn't pushed me to Prozac. A doctor I spoke to today told me that more and more Lebanese are taking anti-depressants, especially those who've lost family members in the bombings. It reminds me of a guy I read about in the southern city of Nabatiyeh last week. He left his house for 15 minutes to stock up on water and returned to find his house flattened in an air strike, his wife and seven children entombed in the rubble. I don't think Prozac is going to help him.

I'm not taking anything stronger than Ambien, these days, but I am starting to stress. And even though I'm exhausted, I sometimes find it hard to sleep at night -- hence the Ambien.

It's just that I've seen things I've never seen before, like a lot of dead people. I was in Tyre, a city in the south, when Israel bombed a shelter in nearby Qana, killing 28 civilians, and where 13 remain missing, presumed buried under the rubble. I spent the morning at the hospital, where they brought the bodies, and watched as civil defense workers laid them out one by one on the pavement in front of the hospital.

The victims looked strangely peaceful in death. As though it had caught them by surprise in their sleep. It was about 1 a.m. when two Israeli bombs struck their shelter two Sundays ago. But because of ongoing air strikes, Red Cross ambulances couldn't arrive for another six hours.

Body of dead child layed out on plastic sheeting.

According to rescue workers, many of the Qana victims had suffocated to death on sand that filled the unfinished basement of the house in which they sheltered.

Mehdi Ahmad Hashim, who looked to be about nine, was dressed in a pair of yellow pajamas with a Spiderman logo. A bruise marked the side of his face; his eyes were shut tight against falling debris from the impact of the two bombs. Ula Ahmad Shalhoub, a girl of about 4, dressed in an orange tee shirt and cotton pants, almost looked as though she was napping, were it not for the sand compacted around her nose. Even her small gold hoop earrings were encrusted in dirt. An older boy of perhaps 16 had died with his mouth open -- his grimace coated with brown dirt. According to rescue workers, many of the victims had suffocated to death on sand that filled the unfinished basement of the house in which they sheltered. They had thought it would protect them against an Israeli air strike. Instead it became their cemetery.

The crowd that gathered outside the hospital was angry. There were shouts of "God is Great" and "Down with America and Israel." The chief of the civil defense tried to bring order to the chaos, as onlookers and photographers shoved and vied for the best view. He yelled at the crowd to respect the dead, striking out at a photographer, who clumsily tripped over one of the bodies. Then his men wrapped the victims in plastic, duct-taping the ends, and identified the first batch of 20, mainly women and children. They waited for the next batch.

Abdel Muhsin Husseini, Tyre's beleaguered mayor appeared. That day's tragedy was just one of many he had faced in the last three weeks of intensive Israeli bombardment of his city and the 66 villages in his district. The day before he had overseen a mass burial of 37 Lebanese from the south.

As he wandered among the wrapped bodies of the Qana victims, he shook his head wearily and said to no one in particular, "So all of these kids were carrying Katyushas?"

Bodies wrapped in plastic are lined up outside a hospital.

Victims of the bombing in Qana are lined up outside the hospital, wrapped in plastic and fastened with duct tape.

As they witness the carnage, my Lebanese friends are increasingly baffled by the Israeli approach. Many can't stand Hezbollah. They realize that Israel is trying to bring the militant group to its knees. But they constantly ask me, "Why are they telling civilians to leave their villages and then strafing them as they flee? Why are they not giving safe passage to urgently needed aid convoys to the south? Why are they forcing hospitals to shut? Why did they bomb our airport, our roads, our milk factories and our army? Why are they punishing all of Lebanon? Do they hate us that much?"

I keep remembering the last time Israel mounted a large-scale invasion of Lebanon in 1982. My aunt and uncle, who were teaching at the American University of Beirut at the time, stuck out that siege of Beirut. Israel bombed the capital for seven weeks. At the time, Israel was trying to bring Yasser Arafat and his Palestine Liberation Organization to its knees. It succeeded, but a year later, with Israeli troops still in Lebanon, something far more radical and dangerous than the PLO was born -- Hezbollah.

I wonder today what new monster will emerge from this violence. What new expression of pain and desire for revenge. Four weeks into the bombing campaign, I'm just starting to feel the mood turn ugly. For the first three weeks, I was amazed by just how humane and gracious the Lebanese remained, especially the displaced, despite their incredible challenges. They patiently told their stories. They offered, with usual Lebanese hospitality, the few cigarettes they had, or a cup of tea. But for good reason, people here are starting to get fed up with journalists, especially Western journalists. Tempers are flaring; people don't really want to talk to Americans, especially since Washington continues to provide Israel with the bombs that are killing their children.

"Why did they bomb our airport, our roads, our milk factories and our army? Why are they punishing all of Lebanon? Do they hate us that much?"

"I will never forget," a civil defense worker screamed at me just yesterday, after spending the night pulling bodies from an apartment building destroyed by a single Israeli bomb in a Beirut suburb. "I will never forget how that pig George Bush killed our children. In the same way," he spat, "we will kill his children."

Of course there's also anger here toward Hezbollah and its patrons Iran and Syria for sparking this mess. I hooked up with Druze leader Walid Jumblatt recently in his 18th century palace in the Chouf Mountains south of Beirut.

He's convinced that an Iranian-Syrian-Hezbollah axis now has the upper hand in Lebanon and is destroying the dream that he fought for last year during the Cedar Revolution -- the dream of a democratic, prosperous Lebanon.

The Iranians he told me are fighting the U.N. over the question of Tehran's nuclear program in Lebanon, while Syria, he said, is happily wreaking revenge for being expelled from Lebanon.

"The fanatics," he told me glumly, "are ruling."

But even Jumblatt does not see where this Israeli campaign is leading. Hezbollah, which has now held out 30 days against Israel and continues to rain rockets on the north, looks victorious in the eyes of the Arab world; it appears to be emerging stronger not weaker from this conflict. At the same time, the pro-Western government of Lebanese Prime Minister Fuad Siniora, the government that Washington helped nurture last year, is increasingly weakened with each passing week of the war.

It's a disaster, Jumblatt told me, and it all stems, as he put it, from America and Israel's "stupid" policies in the Middle East.

Kate Seelye is a Middle East correspondent for Public Radio International's "The World" and a regular contributor to this Web site. Read more of Seelye's dispatches from the region and watch her May 2005 FRONTLINE/World report from Lebanon and Syria following the assassination of Rafik Hariri. You can also listen to Seelye's latest radio reports from Beirut on The World's Web site and learn more about the history of Hezbollah.


Albert Howell - Houston, TX
Reading this blog on the state of Beirut makes me cringe at the senseless horror emanating from my country's blind faith in Israel's bloodthirsty foreign policy. I fear we will awaken too late from our stupor to face what karma must surely have in store for us. I ask G-D to forgive us our sins while bringing our criminal leadership to justice.

issabell bloom - norfork, ar
It seems so horrid, what good could come out of the killing of these souls? Is the bombing of the Lebanese people only a prelude of what is to come as we are sure to go next into Syria and Iran? Where will it stop? Are we to destroy all the Middle East? Look at the mess we have made in Iraq. I don't think the United States cares about these people, not any of them. The current Administration just wants their fossil fuel. I pray that the next administration will be more humanitarian and bring us back to world peace.

This is a catastrophe for Lebanon. The kidnapping of two soldiers has led to the loss of more than 1,000 lives and the destruction of a country that was finally on the road to recovery. Where were all the diplomats? Where was the resolve to prevent confllict by talking instead of letting your military do the talking for you. The so-called leaders of the Western world should be ashamed of themselves for sitting on the sidelines for so long while innocent people died.

How many more innocent people must die in this senseless violence? It seems all I see on CNN and BBC are the faces of dead children in Lebanon.
It fills me with such grief, yet I feel powerless to do anything...other than watch in absolute horror.This report is wonderful in its unbiased retelling on what life feels like for those in the heart of this tragedy.Thank you for this. Hopefully with journalism like this a cease-fire will be forthcoming.