AboutAbout

A group blog composed of scientists, show hosts and producers, Correlations is the official blog of WIRED SCIENCE. Tips, questions or comments? E-mail us at correlations@kcet.org.

BloggersBloggers

Liz Burr
Liz Burr

is the Interactive Project Manager for WIRED SCIENCE Digital.

Damon Gambuto
Damon Gambuto

is a producer on the WIRED SCIENCE television series.

Tamsin Gray
Tamsin Gray

is living in Antarctica to research climate change and the ozone hole.

Chris Hardwick
Chris Hardwick

is a co-host on the WIRED SCIENCE television series.

Clifford Johnson
Clifford Johnson

is a professor of Physics at the University of Southern California.

Sheril Kirshenbaum
Sheril Kirshenbaum

is a marine biologist at Duke University.

Tara C. Smith
Tara C. Smith

is an assistant professor of epidemiology in Iowa.

Michael Tobis
Michael Tobis

is a climatologist at UT Austin working on improving climate models.

Ziya Tong
Ziya Tong

is a host and field producer for WIRED SCIENCE.

WIRED Science blogWIRED Science blog

WIRED Science MyBlogLogWIRED Science MyBlogLog

10.31.07

Notes from the Underground

Damon Gambuto by Damon Gambuto     Department: Behind the Scenes

Experiment Cave is a segment that is close to my heart.  Of course not literally, as we shot the thing more than a mile beneath the ground in Canada.  And of course the heart is a metaphor for my ego.  And ego is a metaphor for my consciousness. . . .okay, I'm boring even me.  

The idea first came across my desk(top) as an email from our fearless leader, David Axelrod.  Daivd is our Executive Producer.  Executive producer can mean a lot of things on a television show.  It can be gifted credit to someone wholly disengaged from the actual production of the show, but generally thought of as a VIP and was around when the idea for the show was first pitched (e.g. Steven Spielberg on ER) or s/he can be the driving creative force on a show.  David is the latter.  He writes, produces and weighs in on just about every frame of WIRED Science and not just because he can.  He really cares.  Which makes all of our jobs here on the show both easier and harder.  Easier because you feel a sense of collaboration and commitment from your boss.  Harder because you feel responsible to that sense of collaboration and commitment from your boss (screwing around on the internet is just not as much fun under these conditions).  High class problems, I know.  Enough smoke blowing. (He's an award winning documentarian too!)  Okay, now I'm done.  (He's also a pilot and has a plane. . . um. . . cool!)  Okay, really.  I'm better than this.

Back to the segment.  So David sends me an article about the deep underground lab in Sudbury and the neutrino hunting they do way down there.  The email reads something like:  "Anything here?"  Which really means:  "I know there is something here, get off your keister and figure it out."  So that's what I did.  

To the research cave!  Or room 205, where the researchers sit and I flit about bothering them.  Researcher Anne Lilburn was put on the case.  Anne is smart, fun, and can run ten miles way faster than you.  Oh, and she has a molecular biology degree from Colgate and a Masters in journalism from Columbia.  I'll be over here in the corner.

"The Lab Down Under" is what I dubbed the segment.  I know.  Totally a way cuter title than what we ultimately went with.  Somehow no one was on board with a Men at Work reference.  

The segment was given to Rick Wilkinson, a producer who was just getting to know me.  Or should I say, he was pretty sure he didn't want to know me?  I don't think it was anything personal (ah, sweet denial).  You see, Rick is a guy who says yes to a two month assignment producing a documentary about a military unit in Iraq.  When he comes back he can tell you about the dignity of the troops, the tragedy of the whole situation, and the wretched fear of living in a war zone without changing his tone.  And then when you ask him to go back and put his life on the line for another month he says yes again.  

When I met him he had come back from what amounted to a second tour in Iraq.  I think he's got the journalist's version of the 1,000 yard stare.  Basically, he wanted me to get out of his way and let him do his job.  Okay, my ego was a little bruised, but I got it.  I stepped out of his way.  Then a cool thing happened.  He asked for my input on his document describing what he'd be shooting.  We call it a "brief" and all of the producers put them together for the higher-ups to read before they head into the field.   I was hesitant as I didn't want to get any further onto his bad side, but then again, this is the kind of stuff they pay me to do.  We worked it out.

Rick had renamed the segment "Deep Science" which I reluctantly admitted was better than my Colin Hay homage.  We batted around ideas about what the story of the segment would be.  We both were so taken by the shear size and scope of the science in this piece that we agreed the story should be the place.  Or, better put, the story would be our adventure into the place.  Rick wrote a great brief.  That and his foursquare recalcitrance when faced with silly questions about how he would accomplish what he had on paper made me like him.  I like him the way you like someone you respect.  What kind of music they listen to or how they spend their weekends is beside the point.  It's not a feeling that happens all the time.

Rick headed to Sudbury with our correspondent Ben Dickow.  Ben is great.  He's tall, handsome and smart, yet makes you feel like you are the one with all the cards.  He's worked in science museums in various capacities and now helps with exhibition design.  He plays in a rock band for fun and is nice like you read about.  Somehow he thought I could give him some guidance on his journey. Umm, take La Cienega to airport.  Despite my failing him as a correspondent coach, we hit it off too.  In fact, the inside story at the mine are anecdotes told to me by Ben.

So here's some interesting stuff.  That far underground, the temperature is pretty warm - between 90 and100 degrees F.  The bare rock in the recently mined tunnel is actually hot to the touch.  Also - going that far underground is dangerous. Before Ben, Rick and our crew went down into the mine, they all had to sign in and take a dog tag, half of which would be kept up topside.  It's there to keep track of bodies in case of a "problem."  Preparing for a "problem" seems like an overly-cautious insurance company mandate.  Except there was one.  While shooting the guys drilling into the rock there was an almost-fire.  A soft box started burning.  Things burning is a BIG "no-no" in a mine.  There are gases that can combust and you are in an enclosed space.  You get the idea.  Everybody was pretty freaked out for about 30 seconds while it was put out.  When the guys who don't think twice about working under millions of tons of shifting earth freak out, you know it's not a good thing.

Also - it's dark underground.  Check out Ben (middle), Rick (right) and our camera operator (left) in their snazzy miner's garb.

clip_image002.jpgThe Experiment Cave is a great piece about the kind of big science that uplifts humanity and introduces us to the biggest questions we can ask.  And it turns out, the key to answering them might very well lie right under our feet... well, way under our feet.




Tags: behind the scenes, ben dickow, canada, cave, david axelrod, heat, production, television, underground

CommentsComments

9 Comments

+ Add Comment

I really appreciate getting the inside scoop on Experiment Cave. It looked like a dangerous segment to film and I guess it was. That’s really cool that you guys at Wired Science would “go deep” and dangerous for a science story. Science doesn’t get the respect, and coverage, it needs.

Your post made me go back and watch the show again online to try and find where the fire might have been. I think I found it at the beginning. Thank you for giving me behind-the-scenes extras. I’ve always wondered what it takes to put a show together. It’s a lot more complicated, and again dangerous, than it looks.

While I watched again, I was reminded of one reason why I liked the segment in the first place. The correspondent, Ben, was really able to blend a respect for the information with a little relaxed humor. His report felt good. Some of the others on the show are either too serious or way too flip and “actor-ish.” That kind of makes them sound like they don’t know what they are reading. Ben seemed to know what he was talking about without sounding stuck up.

Anyway, keep the extra tidbits coming and I’ll keep watching. It's really great to hear what happens behind the curtain.

The experiment cave was a great segment on Wired Science. In fact, I think the subject of neutrinos and other aspects of how we try to gather information about them could have taken much more time than was allotted.

One thing I like about the Experiment Cave bit is that it showed the "human aspect" of gathering data which I think would make it more appealing to those who aren't physicists or engineers. It looks like a lot of work and with some inherent risk involved. Remember, there was a big cave accident just recently in Utah!

Keep up the good work, I would love to learn more about these things.

Props to your whole crew, I greatly enjoyed Experiment Cave! And the way you guys did it made it look like you know what you're doing down there, like it's second nature. The Sun is a great mystery to us humans here on Earth which made this particularly interesting. The way the scientific information was organized and presented made it easy to understand.

I'd like to see more about these unusual science topics, so keep it up!

Thanks for making a science show that does not put my kids to sleep or speak down to them. This segment hit all the right notes-danger, big machines, underground caves and shower caps! Please keep up the good work and know we appreciate it.

This was a great segment, and was kind of symbolic of the challenges of talking about BIG SCIENCE. More and more the "instruments" of science aren't things you hold in your hands, they are buildings, or entire compounds that can employ hundreds of people.

The scale and complexity of this kind of investigation is intimidating, but I thought that your host Ben did an excellent job of "bringing it down to Earth." In the segment he really gave me a sense of the human experience of working in a place like this -- a sense of what the place feels like. This made the science much easier to appreciate and relate to.

In an era when science literacy is an endangered species, this show, and this segment, deserve a pat on the back.

The segment turned out very well. The concentration on one story in one place brought out more science, which is what us geeky people like. As long as you don't lose any staff. . .

Just caught Experiment Cave online and went straight to your blog. What an interesting segment and thanks for the inside info. It would have been nice to see some of the dangerous stuff, if it was filmed, but I'm glad you covered it. BTW, I know that there is a neutrino lab in Minnesota, but it seems like they are more concerned with what neutrinos have to do with the origin of the universe, not just the sun. Is there more info from Canada about that or do they just focus on the sun??

I do have to pick up on what you wrote and say that the host, Ben did a great job. He seems to be truly knowledgable but made the piece understandable, fun, fast paced and clear. Having a real person with an actual science background to be the correspondent.....what a concept! my kind of reality TV, thanks!

Great segment! I really enjoyed learning about such a hefty topic in a very basic and informative way, that didn't overwhelm. The host of the segment, Ben (I think his name???) was really well spoken and seemed to know exactly what he was talking about. He seemed funny too which is exactly what this show needs. Maybe you could let the host of the segment have a little more fun time to just let it out and have at it in the moment?? I wanted to see more information about the scientists and how they arrived at their current occupation/ study ie: what motivated them / inspires them?

bravisima.

More segments like this please! Ben was very good and I hope to see more of him on your show.

Post your comment