Features RSS Feed
69 Comments
Story written by:
Cloning Regulations Could Have Implications for the Economy and Public Health
Chances are it won't be long before our Big Macs come from cloned cows or their offspring. While it's unlikely that the beef itself will hurt us, some experts argue the issue of animal cloning is about more than just the meat on our plates. How our country handles cloning, they say, could have immediate effects on the stability of our food supply, our economy, and, as biotechnology continues to charge forward, future public safety.
Cloning involves creating an exact genetic replica of an existing animal. First, scientists extract the nucleus from an animal cell, which contains the genetic material, and insert it into an egg missing its nucleus. Using various techniques, the egg is coaxed to develop into an embryo that has the exact same genetic "program" as the original animal. Then the embryo is implanted into the womb of a surrogate animal mother. Cloning is beneficial in that it allows breeders to make copies of "star" animals and use them to potentially breed better offspring—and more of them.
But a herd comprised of a number of cloned cows and their offspring could pose some problems, especially when it comes to the stability of our food supply, says Dave Schubert, a cell biologist at the Salk Institute in California. When an epidemic passes through a population of genetically different animals, some die while others survive, thanks to their varied immunological makeups. Herd immunity, as it is called, is the biological basis for the survival of large animal populations, says Schubert. But when there is a population of cloned animals, each of which is genetically identical, herd immunity is lost. Cavendish bananas, all of which are clones, are now under serious attack from a fungal infection; something similar could happen to animals, he says.
"If every Big Mac is made by some cloned population of cows, and half the [human] population eats Big Macs every day, then all of a sudden"—if disaster strikes the cow herd—"there's going to be a lot of skinny people," he says. It's important, therefore, for breeders to limit the number of identical clones they have in any one herd.
It's also possible that our country's regulatory policies—or lack thereof—could make other countries wary of accepting our food exports, and this could spell disaster for the economy, says Debra Strauss, an assistant professor of business law at Fairfield University in Connecticut and a former Food and Drug Law Institute Scholar.
Although the US Food and Drug Administration has not yet made clear exactly how it plans to regulate products made from cloned animals and their offspring—a final regulatory policy should be announced soon—the agency considers cloning to fall under the category of assisted reproductive technology, which includes techniques like artificial insemination and relies on regulatory frameworks set up in 1986. Cloned food products will probably not be regulated any differently than food derived from these other technologies, especially given the agency's announcement earlier this year that cloned food products appear to be completely safe to eat.
"What they're doing is they're taking a new technology, or really the product of the new technology, and fitting it into an old regulatory system," Strauss says.
In addition, the FDA focuses on the concept of "substantial equivalence" to determine whether cloned food is safe, by comparing its nutritional aspects to noncloned food products. But this, Strauss says, fails to give adequate weight to potential risks inherent in the technology.
For instance, recent studies indicate that genetic "tags" called telomeres, which appear on the ends of chromosomes and are associated with aging and genome stability, are significantly shorter in the offspring of clones than in normal animals. While it's unlikely that these modifications will have health effects on people eating the meat, no one yet understands their full implications, and these types of differences would go undetected in the proposed regulatory framework.
The FDA has also indicated that the agency is unlikely to require mandatory labeling on cloned food products, and this could prove problematic if other countries pass labeling regulations, Strauss says. They may not accept foods from the U.S. if they can't be certain which ones came from cloned animals or their offspring. "There's really an interest, for the industry's sake, to do the same sort of labeling that they do overseas," she says.
Another issue surrounds the FDA's handling of transgenic, or genetically modified (GM), animal products—and the agency's handling of cloning could give us a sneak peek at what to expect. Genetic modification is considered distinct from cloning in that actual changes are made to the genetic code. For example, a team of researchers recently engineered pigs with a healthier-than-average ratio of "good" to "bad" fats. But because such changes could potentially interfere with bodily processes and cause allergic reactions, the FDA considers foods derived from genetically modified animals and their offspring to pose more of a health risk than foods made from cloned animals.
"Transgenic animals have to be looked at one at a time," says Jorge Piedrahita, a professor of genomics at North Carolina State University. "The person who made it has to say, OK, I have added a new protein to this animal. I have to prove that that food additive is safe for human consumption."
But according to the US Regulatory Agencies Unified Biotechnology Website, there aren't any planned changes to the regulatory scheme for genetically modified animal products, either. "The United States uses health and safety laws written prior to the advent of modern biotechnology to review genetically engineered products," it says. "To date, the United States has not issued any new legislation for these products."
In the case of GM animal products, other countries are sure to raise a stink about importing them if they are not regulated carefully and labeled. To date, the FDA has not passed any regulations on the labeling of GM foods, Strauss says. The European Union has already passed regulations requiring labeling of these products; if the U.S. does not, then this could be a huge issue for international trade, she says.
Not to mention our safety. Transgenic animals could be a big headache, Schubert says. "We've seen that there's no mechanism to control the unwanted distribution of transgenic plants," he notes, referring to the recent contamination of crops and foods with non-FDA-approved transgenic rice. "So if this happens with transgenic animals in our food supply, then that's a big problem," especially if products are not labeled, as they will be untraceable, he says.
Strauss and Schubert call for mandatory labeling of both cloned and transgenic food products, because at least that allows the consumer to choose, they say. And sometimes, labeling can actually instill consumer confidence in a technology. The executive director of the European Food Safety Organization, Geoffrey Podger, has said that when GM products were first labeled in the UK, they were popular with consumers. It was only when crops began to arrive from North America in which GM and non-GM versions couldn't be distinguished that customers became wary. So labeling can actually promote acceptance, says Strauss.
"If you feel that your government, and in particular your regulatory agencies, are giving you that choice, giving you that respect, then there's much more general trust," she says.
69 Posts
+ Add Comment
10.17.07 7:04 AM PDT
Lisa N. Babcock
It seems to me that cloning as it is now done required a vast and complicated process. For it to be econicly feasible it would have to be automated. As it is now the "natural" system is automated because, bulls do what bulls do!
10.17.07 5:43 PM PDT
richard ryder
name the new cloned beef...
"Cleef" or "Cleeph."
Just a suggestion
10.17.07 5:55 PM PDT
John O'Donnell
This seemed like a unbalanced report very favorable to cloning. There are many problems with cloning and people should investigate themselves many reports of problems with this technology. I raise cattle, and plan to try and get a non-cloned certification if possible so people can eat my beef with confidence that it hasn't been messed with by the out of control cloning and biotechnology companies.
10.17.07 6:11 PM PDT
Daniel B. Davis
This is more of a question than it is a comment. I remember reading about cloning when it first was announced. One of the issues raised involved teleomeres (cell age clocks at the tips of DNA strands) What happened to teleomreres in a clone? The answer was that Dolly's clones were as old as she was, not like newborns.
In the episode, the comment was made that the champion cow was cloned towards the end of her life, suggesting to me that her clones were as old as she. What happened?
10.17.07 6:11 PM PDT
James Williams
It appears to me that there has been no consideration given on what , to me, are two major points.
1. What would be the consequences of corporations gaining "ownership" of favorable genomes. Could this result in corporations having eventual control of the world's food supply?
2. Have any studies been done that rule out the possibility of clones of clones of clones might lead to some form of genetic deficiency from which we might not be able to recover?
There are many profound questions that we have thought of and probably many we have not thought of that may indicate that there is more of a peril to cloning and genetic manipulation than has been anticipated. Much more study is needed before we proceed with this technology in a wholesale fashion.
10.17.07 9:04 PM PDT
Michael Graves
It's unfortunate that viewers are forced to use the internet to get a more balanced and in depth discourse of your cloning 'story'.
The 'wired science' cloning presentation was very unbalanced, emphasizing a pure science view without the always attendant ethical and societal issues and questions (and possible solutions). Although the companion internet
article does address some of the ethical, safety and testing issues, the on air 'story' didn't approach these issues at all. Very myopic and unbalanced science 'story' as opposed to a thorough scientific presentation (which is what one would expect from a show that has 'science' in its title).
10.23.07 9:59 PM PDT
Tess Weir
I agree that the report was biased toward the cloning side of the argument. It seems to me that public broadcasting has lost a little of it's objectiveness. I'm sure there are scientists who might give other view points. All of the scientists and farmers portrayed on your show had economic interest in the forward movement of this technology.
Additionally, I did not like how those who are wary of cloned meat or dairy products are seen as simply uneducated and have no knowledge of the science. We were likened to idiots who just don't understand. The closing of the segment ended up laughing at those who cringe at the thought of cloned beef; and the remedy is for the wary to just get over our 'misconceptions' about what cloning is all about. It even suggested that a new name is all that is needed.
I will be following this issue and will push for labeling of cloned beef. I would like to give my idiot-money to the farmer who proudly denounces the practice of cloned beef.
10.27.07 9:25 AM PDT
mallory
i think cloning is wrong and ridiculous.
i think they should just stop all of it.
just saying.
11.12.07 11:58 PM PST
galileo
Cloning has many problems, but as well pointed out by others, you chose not to speak, show or discuss them. Your science is bogus science, 'wired' science, useless.
We have real problems that have real solutions that need to be discussed. Instead you speak with Miss Prima Donna who wants to put 'perfect' beef on American tables. Well, Miss WS, the beef is not perfect, it's chokeful of pesticides, herbicides, hormones, fungicides, steroids, chemicals. It's full of antibiotics because it is the only way those clones survice, if at all, with massive internal hemorragies and organ collapse. Your attempts at putting a human face into an in-human activity is a crime. We are not stupid. The nation is not stupid. We have honest scientits and citizens, and you are an affront and offense to us. Your program is a waste of time and energy, and should go off the air immediately.
1.14.08 7:52 AM PST
cody markham
I think that cloning is crazy!!!!I mean,Who came up with it? Do you know what I mean? Ya,I would like to have a few cloned dogs,if I have a rare dog right.Then I could be rich!
4.2.08 3:38 PM PDT
Travis
I don't think this article is leaning toward cloning of animals at all. I find this article very informative and gives views from both sides of the issue. As for cloning it could help farmers provide consumers with the best cuts of meat at a cheaper price. Also it may help the farmer that continues to grow his beef the old fashion way with a niche market. In the end everyone comes out ahead. I think the galileo guy is very wrong about herbicides and antibiotics he sould read some of the standards placed on the agriculture industry the science he is refering to is bogus.
7.23.08 8:35 PM PDT
SciFi Film
Too much clone product promo, and since when is "Blade Runner' about clones, wasn't it androids?
7.21.09 7:50 PM PDT
cialis online
LBaJ4B hmeuxpoz tovrskdr tnetnsbr
7.25.09 3:06 AM PDT
cialis kaufen
hrwkmdjp ylckmpux ytiyvori
7.30.09 9:30 PM PDT
acquista viagra
hysyrogh gfsmwqpj uozcdtbd
7.30.09 10:22 PM PDT
acquista viagra
pvtzoykr hzecjabn nyydjtzj
7.30.09 11:12 PM PDT
cialis generico
sqlexdkr xzzrifsj qbevkqfn
7.31.09 12:05 AM PDT
compra viagra
mwtojotr fshngqep hbjuehrw
7.31.09 12:56 AM PDT
viagra generico
ypkqwqqa uqjbmbwe scgimpyf
7.31.09 1:46 AM PDT
viagra prix en pharmacie
vurbdgcq aeqtxkzl tqcnlopc
7.31.09 2:37 AM PDT
cialis france
ldgvvxyr aajggsdi chsfdmpc
7.31.09 3:29 AM PDT
viagra
mspoczyh vufassum nfzsxkhd
7.31.09 4:18 AM PDT
acquista cialis
uwgtuyrs hnmwrbhr wiwunuvf
7.31.09 5:09 AM PDT
acquista viagra
eimbipqx tdewaadk dzspyiat
7.31.09 4:49 PM PDT
viagra senza ricetta
xopkvidr yznrdnna mbtbzngd
7.31.09 6:10 PM PDT
levitra omeopatico
zmyvwzid oyvailid wykqkeim
7.31.09 7:29 PM PDT
100mg cialis
yiuicnci fbzlpecx urgkqude
7.31.09 8:50 PM PDT
cialis online cialis
ofcjnffs rlrzzqtl hydksodc
7.31.09 10:11 PM PDT
viagra torrinomedica
hxfdysbl nzszguus sxmhirhx
8.9.09 6:19 AM PDT
kamagra
rcgtkgxt zsgfzcal wluxemin
8.9.09 7:43 AM PDT
Levitra
yjvhftlp dbeobshf ougywmzf
8.9.09 9:09 AM PDT
viagra
kiwnlnxu afhsyfvx fvbhohyn
8.9.09 10:32 AM PDT
viagra prix
hygslnuc tbmxkobw dzibgkhm
8.9.09 11:55 AM PDT
viagra
lznvhxin zbqwmhkv yxggetud
8.14.09 12:27 AM PDT
prix cialis
suwtlced xrthpcrc hvckiqiw
8.14.09 1:52 AM PDT
achat viagra
ctggemww yfbbkvkm ujxroekm
8.14.09 3:15 AM PDT
viagra france
qukxvrwu yaxvhuft kcwpmkgg
8.14.09 4:39 AM PDT
viagra achat
prhfclov djncdugp ncaplzon
8.14.09 6:05 AM PDT
vente viagra
aytdwupg cjtutfei jubuguwt
8.14.09 7:32 AM PDT
vente viagra
ymcruotl tlzjowtr exqpvmgh
8.14.09 9:00 AM PDT
prix cialis
goklhrwp jnkpnigi axtowwno
8.14.09 10:26 AM PDT
viagra
raozoygd maboyzqu ecssjovh
8.14.09 11:50 AM PDT
viagra
tzintblz cvxtirxz ldmkjlkc
8.14.09 1:14 PM PDT
vente viagra
uontuxuq pilxsrwf thmjdvaz
8.17.09 9:17 PM PDT
viagra kaufen online
olzsmanh zokqqkwq srmxzzei
8.17.09 10:56 PM PDT
viagra
brzadjgc ymxfrnss wkqmxjks
8.18.09 12:36 AM PDT
viagra preis
uqucivls bjqgiigb binyxvkp
8.18.09 2:18 AM PDT
viagra
hfzhtjpm duasyfte irhuqwqy
8.18.09 8:34 PM PDT
viagra prix
rnqschco fhkxvadd qlzonogb
8.19.09 1:21 AM PDT
acheter du viagra
jgvhhndf oddlvjus nelchrum
8.20.09 4:45 PM PDT
acquistare cialis generico
nxcmlnwz qmgvvkty zgyiuatb
8.20.09 10:44 PM PDT
cialis online
sycgosfz scualprp bwhyrmkm
8.21.09 4:39 AM PDT
acquisto viagra in farmacia
hgqbtqme hpbtwjoh txpsfljn
8.21.09 10:38 AM PDT
acquistare cialis generico
jnquwzcl twfwmpxi hsvnrdyb
8.21.09 3:04 PM PDT
acquistare viagra online
dexbggyg jcmamwtv rijcgxmy
8.21.09 9:03 PM PDT
cialis
xtctbujl dxvjqvhj udbgbdfx
8.22.09 9:34 AM PDT
acheter cialis en france
izripndn cnxigkuy logxpwmw
8.22.09 11:22 AM PDT
cialis
nwnoejjc uyqgxkza xiyybrdq
8.22.09 1:07 PM PDT
cialis
swyatrfm qzylhmmy lrunazyj
8.28.09 1:01 PM PDT
compra viagra italia
wxhhzprk bewjeahg uzpwqcsf
8.28.09 2:40 PM PDT
acquisto viagra senza ricetta
dpntmnjk ammuybdb htyuwvmb
8.28.09 4:17 PM PDT
acquisto cialis generico
igqjkequ twxgerrl hwydmqxy
8.28.09 5:55 PM PDT
acheter viagra en ligne
oenlsvdb kmjctwcz jhhseeyb
8.28.09 7:37 PM PDT
acquisto viagra on line
akyfiiot xirpbojr wwsvdlfh
8.28.09 9:17 PM PDT
viagra generico
ushloxfm jktirdgf sntktdqp
8.28.09 10:55 PM PDT
acquisto viagra in farmacia
aypeenzr kgggtflz gffgzcsp
8.29.09 12:31 AM PDT
acheter cialis
jltkresy quiffjrz lhjiquen
8.29.09 2:10 AM PDT
acquistare viagra online
zlwqorav vinuykaj phqqsfty
8.29.09 3:49 AM PDT
achat viagra
rxnwgbas xbzzpfoa vangyamd
Post your comment