1814 Dr. Solomon's Dilemma
Air date: April 4, 2000
Dr. Solomon's Dilemma
Written and Produced by
Hedrick Smith and David Murdock
Hedrick Smith, Correspondent
ANNOUNCER: Tonight on FRONTLINE: There is a new battle for the soul of
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Every month, we see how deep in the red we are.
ANNOUNCER: A war between caring and costs.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I don't care how much you fool yourself. It has to
affect the way you make decisions.
ANNOUNCER: Will we be the casualties?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: In the moral, real world, we don't have a choice.
We have to provide the care, but we can't go on doing that forever for
HEDRICK SMITH, Correspondent: And from the perspective of the
ANNOUNCER: Correspondent Hedrick Smith examines the conflict that is
pitting doctor against doctor.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: From the perspective of the patient they may not be
getting necessarily the best care.
ANNOUNCER: Tonight on FRONTLINE, Dr. Solomon's Dilemma.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Boston, 6:00 AM. Inside one of
Harvard's famed teaching hospitals, the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center,
in the cardiac intensive care unit, Sam Armstrong is fighting for his life.
Dr. Marty Solomon is his primary care physician.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: [to patient] Hey, Sam. Good morning.
How're you doing this morning?
He's been in the hospital now something in excess of six weeks, in the
intensive care unit for just about the entire stay, requiring very, very
complex medical care.
So far it looks as if the infection's coming under control. Your heart seems
to be working okay. The wound is looking better.
HEDRICK SMITH: But patient care is not the only thing on Solomon's
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I'm sure this hospitalization is well in excess of
$150,000 already. We're not going to get reimbursed for that total amount.
The hospital's not going to get reimbursed for the total amount. His care is
going to be, basically, a loser. People are going to lose money on caring for
In the moral, real world, we don't have a choice. We have to provide the care,
but we can't go on doing that forever for everybody. I'm very conflicted in
providing the care that I know the patient needs, and yet I know that I'm
losing money when I see this patient. And if I have more patients like this,
as I do, then I'm losing more and more money.
And there comes a point at which I can no longer afford to do it because I
can't- I can't do anything.
HEDRICK SMITH: Dr. Solomon's dilemma epitomizes a new phase of managed
care, one that is fueling a furious debate among doctors about the very soul of
medicine and eroding the precious bond of trust between doctors and
[on-camera] Good evening. I'm Hedrick Smith.
For a decade, American health care has been the story of employers and HMOs
telling doctors to cut costs. Tonight a new story at the frontier of health
care: doctors rebelling and taking power back from HMOs.
The teaching hospitals around Harvard Medical School are taking a lead in
this bold initiative. Their idea is that with doctors back in control,
patients will get better care and hospitals will make enough money to
But there's a catch. Taking control means assuming financial risk. The
more care they give, the more it costs them directly. So the sickest patients
become not just people in need but money losers. This conflict of interest now
pits doctor versus doctor, and patients are caught in the middle.
[voice-over] It's no accident that this debate rages fiercely in
Boston. For decades Boston has been one of the world's great medical Meccas.
Some of the finest hospital and research facilities anywhere on Earth are here,
crowded around Harvard Medical School in a remarkable area called Longwood.
And yet even in this Mecca something is wrong. Everyone - hospitals, health
plans, and doctors like Marty Solomon - are in crisis over money.
Marty Solomon has been practicing primary care medicine for over 20 years.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: This is where I grew up. From the time I was 5
years old, this is where I used to walk to school, go to the stores,
playground- I used to play baseball down there.
And the thing that is neat about practicing around here is I now take care of
people who were the elders when I was a kid, like the policeman who used to
stand on the corner there when I used to walk to school, and the guy who ran
the pharmacy that used to be over here. They're all patients of mine now.
It's really neat.
HEDRICK SMITH: Such nostalgia is a luxury. Though Solomon is regularly
named one of Boston's top primary care physicians, he is a driven man. After
pre-dawn visits to his patients in the hospital, Solomon opens his office. It
is the last quiet moment of his day.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Open your mouth wide.
MALE PATIENT: Aaahhh.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Okay, now swallow.
HEDRICK SMITH: Over the next 10 hours he will see about 35 patients.
MALE PATIENT: This August I got a case of jock itch I couldn't
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Hold your breath.
Just lift your chin up.
FEMALE PATIENT: Which one?
HEDRICK SMITH: Every day he gets about 100 phone calls and answers 50
emails. One weekend a month he's on call.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: [on the phone] You don't have to work on her
for an hour to bring her back if she should arrest.]
HEDRICK SMITH: Like many other doctors, Solomon is increasingly
dissatisfied with his work.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: The worst experiences I've had in my professional
career have been within the past few years, dealing with patients on issues of
managed care, where we're trying to control costs.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: If you go out of the network we have to pay it,
actually, and we have to pay it out of our resources.
It's really been heartbreaking.
I'm tired of sending them people. They give them three injections, and they
end up with no relief.
HEDRICK SMITH: Marty Solomon and his colleagues are in a bind. Trained
to care for patients no matter what the cost, they're now being told they must
watch the bottom line.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN, CEO, CareGroup Healthcare System: Doctors today
are talking about money because money is the crisis that we're facing. It's
the "no margin, no mission" issue. The pressures they're getting on dollars
come from payers, they come from administrators, they come from their
department chairs. They come from everywhere.
HEDRICK SMITH: And they come from each other.
Dr. SUSAN FRANKL: [physicians' meeting] There's an issue about
one of your patients, Dr. Katz.
HEDRICK SMITH: Doctors in Boston are being organized in small groups -
called pods - to make them focus on the cost of the care they give.
Dr. KATZ: He got sick enough to come to the hospital, and they sent him
to St. E's. We have to get the details.
HEDRICK SMITH: In this meeting, one doctor is being singled out because
one of his patients was sent to a competing hospital. This will be costly to
his medical group.
Dr. KATZ: And I found out because the wife, who I also take care of,
was in my office for an unrelated problem and said, "Did you know my husband
was"- and I had egg on my face. I had no idea.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: We have to be certain that there is some
notification on that record, such that when a patient goes to the emergency
room, there are people there know that they must call us for permission.
HEDRICK SMITH: The one forcing them to focus on the bottom line is Dr.
Jim Reinertsen, CEO of the CareGroup hospital network.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: We need to get into the black by next fall. We
need to achieve a sense of operational discipline that we have not had
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: So there's lots of things going on at the pod level
HEDRICK SMITH: Solomon and his pod, in essence, work for Jim Reinertsen
because they've all sold their practices to CareGroup. CareGroup is a network
of seven hospitals, 3,000 doctors and 400,000 patients. Last year it delivered
$1 billion worth of health care - and lost $100 million.
Reinertsen's point man in the drive to control costs is medical efficiency
expert, Dr. Kim Saal.
Dr. KIM SAAL, CareGroup Medical Director: I see my role as one to
promote change, to constantly force change in the system. It is changing
behavior of patients. It's changing behavior of physicians. And that's a
tough road to go down.
HEDRICK SMITH: A part-time cardiologist, Saal is CareGroup's full-time
medical director. The key to saving money, Saal believes, is reining in
Dr. KIM SAAL: I think that doctors control 80 percent of health care
costs with their pens. Therefore, I think it is critical that the doctor has
some responsibility for that cost incurred.
HEDRICK SMITH: In effect, Saal has taken on the role traditionally
played by HMOs.
Dr. KIM SAAL: Doctors' first response was, "We really appreciate that
it has shifted from the health plans giving the guidance to now doctors giving
guidance." Over the two years that I've had this job, all of a sudden now I'm
looked at as the health plan. They're no longer very appreciative of it.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] Maybe they're right. You really do
have the killer job.
Dr. KIM SAAL: People ask me what do I do, and I tell them what my job
is. They all stare at me and say to me, "Why would you ever take that job?"
Very often, I think they are right.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] To focus doctors on costs, Saal and
his aides must transform patient care into data.
Dr. KIM SAAL: If you cannot measure it, you cannot manage it. So the
first thing we do is develop standards by which we can measure care.
HEDRICK SMITH: Every day in the hospital, every pill, every test, every
shot is transformed into a dollar figure and passed along to the individual
doctors. Saal uses these numbers to prod physicians into changing their
At his fingertips, Saal has data collected by health plans that tell him how
doctors practice medicine and how much they're spending. He sat down with me
and focused on the numbers for Dr. Solomon's Pod 11.
Dr. KIM SAAL: And here you can see that Dr. Solomon is spending more
money for radiology services than the average physician in the system. And we
can now analyze that further to see that, indeed, he spends, on average, $2
more than his pod of physicians. Over time, his costs over the past year have
gone from about $10 a month per patient, to now over $12 per month per
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So if your whole system was like
Solomon, you'd be spending $12 million more on radiology than you are now?
Dr. KIM SAAL: Correct.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Those numbers take on special
urgency when your team is losing $100 million a year.
[on-camera] So when you say the pressures are dramatic today- what, I
mean, "Guys, we got to bring it down, immediately"?
Dr. KIM SAAL: "Guys, we've got to bring it down over time." We have to
show the trends are not going in the direction of this pharmacy cost, but going
in the opposite direction."
HEDRICK SMITH: And it's got to happen sooner rather than later.
Dr. KIM SAAL: Absolutely. It does.
HEDRICK SMITH: One of the things that we see in the new medicine is a
tremendous focus on data, performance data, report cards. What do you, as a
pod leader, get from the higher-ups?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, we get very detailed reports. I should have
a few here in the drawer. Let's see. Pharmacy costs- this is the amount of
money that is being spent per patient. We know exactly per patient. This next
graph down here looks at how effective we've been at trying to reduce the
number of days people stay in the hospital.
Then here's another one looking at admissions out of CareGroup. We can then
break them down, actually, by physician and by patient. For example, office
visits, in-patient visits, in-patient and out-patient surgery, all broken down
by cost, interestingly, by cost per unit. You notice this is the insurance
company's term, not "cost per patient" but "cost per unit" and-
HEDRICK SMITH: They're not people any more.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: No, they're units.
DOCTOR: [pod meeting] Once again, these are PCP-specific
reports. Take yours, and pass the others along, as always.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] These figures are passed out at Pod
11 meetings and studied by the group.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: Doctors spent many, many years getting very good
report cards, and they want to get good report cards. And their behaviors
change rather rapidly when they realize that their colleagues are doing better
than they are.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: [to patient] Now I want you to take some
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] Can you be that statistical and that
abstract about something as unpredictable as medical care?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I don't- you know, I can't. I just deliver the best
care I can and hope we do it right and try and be conscious of all these
factors, but you just can't think about it all the time. You can't worry
whether the care that you're giving is going to throw these figures off.
But unfortunately, what they're telling us is that we do have to worry about
it. So every time I write a prescription, every time I order a test, every
time I send a patient to the emergency room or refer them to another doctor,
this is somewhere in the back of my mind. "How is that going to look on the
figures next month?"
Even if I don't want it to, I know that next month I'm going to sit down with
the other doctors in the group, and we're going to look at these figures. And
everybody's going to say, "Well," you know, "what can we do to make this
better?" And what we can do is, do less of what we're doing.
Dr. KIM SAAL: We are rationalizing health care. I'm not sure patients
want to hear that. I'm not sure doctors want to hear that. But we need to
make a decision. We don't have an open checkbook. [www.pbs.org: Read more
of the interviews]
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Some doctors in Pod 11, like Bill
Goldberg, are uneasy with this approach.
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG, Pod 11 Doctor: So they have everything analyzed- my
prescription costs, my radiology costs, surgical costs, OB-GYN costs.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] How do you feel about this grading
system, being graded? Does it ever get personal?
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: Yeah.
HEDRICK SMITH: It does?
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: I think it does, yeah.
HEDRICK SMITH: In what way?
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: You know, basically, you know, there's a sense that
you're naked. You know, there are 10 physicians who are showing per patient,
per month, what they pay for pharmacy cost, for what they pay for X-rays, for
what they pay to the surgeons, what they pay for birth control pills.
So it's a certain personal- because you're sharing some stuff that I don't
think, you know, it's always that comfortable to share.
HEDRICK SMITH: You're naked in front of whom?
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: Your colleagues.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Other Pod 11 doctors, like hospital
board member Jeffrey Bass, like getting the numbers.
Dr. JEFFREY BASS, Pod 11 Doctor: If there are patients who are getting
a lot of physical therapy visits, if my utilization of X-rays for a given
problem is higher than the average for our overall physician group, if my use
of medications is higher, that is information that I can take back and say,
"Well," you know, "if I'm doing this more than others, maybe it can be done
differently, and maybe it can be done better." I don't think it's bad
information for me.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] Do you keep it handy? Do you keep a
Dr. JEFFREY BASS: I do.
HEDRICK SMITH: Now, do you keep those numbers? Do you have the
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: Actually, I don't keep them.
HEDRICK SMITH: You don't keep them.
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG: I don't keep them. I read them, I study them, I see
where- and I throw them away.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] But Dr. Goldberg can't discard the
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: [pod meeting] Those numbers are actually
HEDRICK SMITH: -"Think dollars and cents."
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: We know that we're really in a hole. Everybody's
salary and contract is on the line. And the numbers are shown to us on a
regular basis. Every month, we see how deep in the red we are.
HEDRICK SMITH: Pod 11's struggle with red ink is a microcosm of the
larger battle for economic survival at CareGroup and at almost every medical
institution in Boston. Dr. Philip Boulter is medical director at Tufts Health
Plan, which lost $41 million last year.
Dr. PHILIP BOULTER, Chief Medical Officer, Tufts Health Plan: I'm not
sure anybody knows what is really wrong in this marketplace. It's known for its
high quality of the medical facilities. It's a bastion of medical education.
It has the highest cost. And yet over the past - and I would just say the past
several years - the hospitals, the physicians and the health plans, all the
segments of this population are now losing money.
HEDRICK SMITH: Including the largest health plan, Harvard Pilgrim,
which plunged into state receivership in 1999, and CareGroup's rival hospital
network, a Goliath called Partners, which ran $47 million in the red last
CareGroup lost roughly twice that much, trapped between lower payments from
employers and the government and higher costs for the expensive new cures that
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: Federal cuts in payment, decreased rates of
payment in managed care contracts, and rapidly rising costs for new, exciting
technologies like pharmaceuticals and other things- that's the triple threat
that we have faced and has caused the red ink in the Boston market.
HEDRICK SMITH: Three years ago, CareGroup thought it saw a way out by
taking on the risk of controlling costs in return for a larger share of premium
income from the HMOs. But the money hemorrhage continued, prompting health care
executives like Reinertsen to call for a radical overhaul.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: Right now, this system is producing $5 million
monthly losses. It's perfectly designed to do that. And we're going to have
to change almost every aspect of this system if we're going to get to break
even and above.
HEDRICK SMITH: CareGroup's flagship hospital, Beth Israel Deaconess,
has already endured six years of cutbacks and layoffs. And in late 1999, its
president, Dr. Herb Kressel, agonized over the impact of still more cuts.
Dr. HERB KRESSEL, Pres., Beth Israel Deaconess: My toughest problem is
to be able to sustain the caring relationship in an era of rapidly declining
revenues and resources. There is this argument health care is a business and it
is appropriate that we respond to the business imperatives. But people
obtaining health care are not just obtaining a product, no matter how we call
it. They're seeking a relationship with caring that helps them get through
very, very difficult times.
HEDRICK SMITH: Losing sight of patients is the major worry of many
veteran physicians like Dr. Tom Delbanco, the hospital's chief of general
medicine. [www.pbs.org: More on cost vs. care]
Dr. TOM DELBANCO, Chief of General Medicine: I'm terrified by all the
forces that are buffeting us these days. If we forget what we're really about,
if we forget to keep our eye on that ball, which is the doctor-patient, the
clinician-patient, that individual unique relationship, we're going to be
HEDRICK SMITH: In the new health care model, time is money- time in the
hospital, time on the operating table, time in the doctor's office. The
combination of managed care and advanced technology has cut the length of
hospital stays by 25 percent nationwide in the last decade.
But as the painful story of Steve Bookbinder illustrates, this emphasis on time
drives the lives of both hospital and patient. Steve had a premium health plan
with special benefits, but even so he was put on the hospital's efficiency
STEVE BOOKBINDER: I was in good physical shape. And I'd never smoked
or drank or, you know, done anything really excessive.
HEDRICK SMITH: At 52, Steve needed a special test of his heart, a
cardiac catheterization. Years ago, this procedure involved several days in
the hospital. His cardiologist, Dr. Julian Aroesty, remembers that time.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY, Cardiologist: Those were the halcyon days of
medicine when everybody was insured, when you thought about delivering the very
best care you could and didn't think too much about what it cost to do so.
HEDRICK SMITH: It was also the time when insurers paid for each day in
the hospital, so there was little incentive to move patients out quickly.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: Now we want things done - putting this in quotes -
HEDRICK SMITH: "Efficiently" because today hospitals negotiate flat -
or "capitated" - rates with health plans, in this case, about $500 for a
catheterization. So now it's in the hospital's financial interest to move the
patient out quickly. [www.pbs.org: How does capitation work?]
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: I think for patients it is a different kind of
experience, and one that's a little bit more frightening.
HEDRICK SMITH: The medical team works rapidly. a tube is inserted up
the groin and into the heart.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: Steve, you're going to get a hot feeling now. It
will go from your head to your toes, last for just a couple of seconds and then
pass off. I'll let you know when it's coming.
Hot feeling coming. Inject.
HEDRICK SMITH: They inject dye into the bloodstream to check how well
the heart is pumping blood.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: Breathe.
Remember that the news that they're going to get is either "You're fine," or
that "You have something that needs to be taken care of, and we have taken care
of it or you need a heart operation."
Steve, we're all done.
HEDRICK SMITH: For Bookbinder, the news is not good.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: The amount of territory in jeopardy is fairly
large. And that's the thing that sort of bothers us the most. So best treated
by an operation, I think.
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Okay, which means bypass.
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: Bypass.
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Wow.
HEDRICK SMITH: Back in the room, Bookbinder and his wife, Susan, absorb
the news and prepare to go home.
STEVE BOOKBINDER: I've never been hospitalized, except once before.
And I went quickly home and I adjusted, even though I didn't feel completely
safe. And I guess I'll go home this time and adjust, even though I may not
feel completely safe.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] Do you have a feeling that maybe the
health system is throwing too much on you, the family, too soon?
SUSAN BOOKBINDER: I feel like we have to assimilate things very fast,
and that's what causes this emotion in me. And I feel, like, "Okay. If I have
to, I have to." And I know I react physically to it, definitely. "Whoa! This
is really too much."
Dr. JULIAN AROESTY: Is it safer to keep the patient in another day, or
is it just as safe to send them home the same day? Well, yes, it is just the
same to send them home the same day from the standpoint of safety. So a
same-day admission, same-day discharge after a catheterization is equally safe.
But is it equally good medical care? Probably not.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Four days after the test, Steve
undergoes open-heart surgery like this. For a quadruple bypass and all
associated care for the next 90 days, the hospital normally receives a flat or
capitated fee of $30,000, getting the same amount of money whether the patient
stays in the hospital five days or ten days after surgery.
Steve is out in three.
STEVE BOOKBINDER: I was operated on last Tuesday afternoon, and I was
discharged on Friday afternoon at about 2:00 o'clock.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So you were in the hospital for 72
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Yeah. I was under the knife at this point a week
HEDRICK SMITH: Wow. It's amazing. Doesn't that amaze you a little
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Yeah, it does.
HEDRICK SMITH: Can we look and see what- what they did to you?
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Sure. Well here's what the leg looks like. I mean,
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Steve is glad to be home-
STEVE BOOKBINDER: This is what my chest looks like.
HEDRICK SMITH: -but uneasy about the speed of his release.
STEVE BOOKBINDER: Well, my concern is that the health system might take
my experience of being in the hospital for three nights and doing well, you
know, on the fourth day, outside the hospital and say, "Well, that works for
everybody else, and therefore the model for quadruple bypasses ought to be
three nights in the hospital." That I'd be worried about.
HEDRICK SMITH: In fact, Bookbinder is the model. His swift, three-day
hospital stint matches medical guidelines adopted by Bookbinder's health
insurer, Tufts. These guidelines are used as yardsticks nationwide as health
plans shift the financial risk for care to hospitals. Instead of hospitals
being paid - as they used to be - for each service they provide, they now
gamble on providing total care within the guidelines and making a profit.
Under the guidelines, for instance, the length of stay in the hospital for an
appendectomy should be one day. Caesarean section? Two days. Coronary
bypass? Three days.
Dr. Frank Sellke, the surgeon who operated on Bookbinder, is comfortable with
Dr. FRANK SELLKE, Cardiothoracic Surgeon: We always try to increase the
efficiency. For each individual patient, it doesn't really matter if you go
home on the third or fourth or the fifth post-operative day. But if you do a
thousand heart operations, like we do at this institution, whether you send a
patient home one day earlier can have a tremendous effect on the- the financial
health of the institution.
HEDRICK SMITH: The day after we saw Bookbinder on his treadmill, the
guidelines suddenly went out the window.
SUSAN BOOKBINDER: At 3:00 o'clock in the morning, I noticed that he
wasn't in bed. And I went to find him, and he said he had this heaviness in
his heart, and he was on the phone with the doctor. He just felt this real
heaviness on his heart. And Dr. Aroesty said, "I want you to come to the
emergency room." It came up that it was staph.
HEDRICK SMITH: Back in the hospital, Steve had to have his chest
reopened to deal with a staph infection. He and his wife, Susan, were in
SUSAN BOOKBINDER: And they all say, "Oh, yeah. We've seen this. We've
seen- it's- you're going to be okay." But it's- somehow, there's something
about it that doesn't- is not quite as reassuring. They're all doing their
job, and they're doing it right. But you, as a patient, just don't really know
HEDRICK SMITH: Bookbinder's infection meant three more weeks in the
Dr. FRANK SELLKE, Cardiothoracic Surgeon: He probably became a money
loser after he went back to the operating room for treatment of his
complication because the operating room costs are significant, and the hospital
is not reimbursed that much for the operation. If everything goes well, they
do very well, but if there's a major complication, they tend to lose money.
HEDRICK SMITH: Risa Dinman-Lavelle represents in this risk-based
environment another kind of complication for a teaching hospital.
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: I can't get out of the chair!
HEDRICK SMITH: Pregnant with her third child, she has type one
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: It means monitoring my sugars a lot, testing my
blood, taking my insulin, seeing the doctor. I mean, everything revolves
around the diabetes.
HEDRICK SMITH: A generation ago, most women with diabetes were
counseled against getting pregnant. The stress put on blood sugar levels
during pregnancy can result in frequently premature and malformed babies and
hasten the onset of kidney, heart and vascular problems in the mothers.
PHYSICIAN: How've you been doing the last two weeks?
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: Okay, but I've definitely had some changes.
HEDRICK SMITH: But specialty clinics like the Joslin Diabetes Center,
part of CareGroup, pioneered the technology and the team approach to helping
diabetic women deliver healthy babies.
PHYSICIAN: Okay. Good. You're getting most of your kicks here?
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: I'm getting it everywhere.
HEDRICK SMITH: Doctors, nurse educators, ophthalmologists,
nutritionists and other special care givers all help diabetics maintain their
blood sugar levels throughout the pregnancy. The hospital gets paid at the
same rate as a normal pregnancy, about $1,500, but its costs can be four or
five times that much.
Dr. ALAN MOSES: Diabetes is an expensive disease.
HEDRICK SMITH: Dr. Alan Moses, chief medical officer of Joslin.
Dr. ALAN MOSES: In order to effectively treat a patient with diabetes,
you have to understand the patient, and I think what's been removed from the
practice of medicine is the interaction between- the meaningful quality
interaction between patient and physician.
HEDRICK SMITH: In the last decade, the time a patient actually sees a
doctor has been cut to an average of seven minutes, according to some studies.
The Joslin Center needs much more time.
Dr. ALAN MOSES: I don't think it's possible to effectively care for a
patient with diabetes in seven to ten minutes. You can, in fact, do a better
job meeting the financial needs of the practice by seeing patients more
quickly. But I don't think you've really addressed the major issue, which is
how do you effectively take care of the patient.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So you can take care of the bottom
line but not the patient?
Dr. ALAN MOSES: Right. I think that's the battle that we're facing.
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: We're just getting bigger by the day here!
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Risa returns to her medical team 30
times during her pregnancy, spending about an hour each visit.
RISA DINMAN-LAVELLE: The Joslin gives such incredible care. And you
have to be proactive being diabetic. You can't wait for the problems to
happen. And that's why I go there.
This is a disease that you have to think 20 years down the road. It's- right
now I'm in great shape, I'm in great health, but 20 years down the road will be
affected by what I do now. So for me, I want to be healthy, and I want to live
as long as I can.
HEDRICK SMITH: High quality, pro-active care with lots of patient
education may prolong life, but it puts Joslin in a financial hole.
[on-camera] So are you losing money on patient care?
Dr. ALAN MOSES: Sure.
HEDRICK SMITH: Much?
Dr. ALAN MOSES: Sure.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Joslin loses nearly $5 million a
year on patient care. Its losses were a major issue three years ago, when
hospitals were choosing up sides in Boston's merger wars. The doctors at the
newly formed CareGroup faced the difficult decision of what to do about Joslin.
Dr. TOM DELBANCO, Chief of General Medicine: The Joslin Clinic was an
interesting example of how we think these days. Here is a world-famous place
taking good care of very sick people and advancing knowledge about diabetes.
Should we join with them? Well, we suddenly found ourselves sounding like
businessmen. What are the up, down dollar implications?
HEDRICK SMITH: Within CareGroup, administrators such as then vice
president Andrew Brotman had to rethink their traditional relationship with
ANDREW BROTMAN, Former VP, CareGroup: So the debate within CareGroup
and between CareGroup and the Joslin became, "Of course we want to take care of
people with diabetes. Of course we want to find a cure. Of course we want to
train physicians to be able to do this and work together. But on the other
hand, if the economics dramatically change, we can go bankrupt on this. We
will lose extraordinary amounts of money because our patient population will be
sicker, and therefore it can bring the system down.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] Too many sick people?
ANDREW BROTMAN: Too many sick people.
HEDRICK SMITH: First time in my life I've actually heard doctors- not
accountants, not journalists, not politicians, but doctors talking about too
many sick people. How do you respond to that?
Dr. ALAN MOSES: I think we have this perversity in our system because
we're here to help sick people. I mean that should be our mission. We're here
to improve the quality of their lives, to decrease the impact of diabetes on
their lives, to decrease the complications that are associated with diabetes.
If we can't do that, I'm not sure why we should be here at all.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] And so Risa's baby girl - all 10
pounds, 13 ounces- contributed to red ink at both Joslin and Beth Israel
The time squeeze is especially tough on leading academic hospitals like
CareGroup's Beth Israel Deaconess because their mission makes them inherently
inefficient. They take care of the most challenging and costly patients. They
perform very expensive research, which takes time away from care. And they
must teach the next generation of doctors, a task that is enormously
Until now, academic hospitals have always been protected from the marketplace
because society valued their contribution. But in just three years, Congress
has cut funds to teaching hospitals by $2.2 billion. And Beth Israel president
Dr. Herb Kressel sees the academic mission in jeopardy.
[on-camera] I mean, your finance committee meets every month trying to
figure out which of the components aren't delivering to the bottom line.
Dr. HERB KRESSEL, Pres., Beth Israel Deaconess: Correct. And there are
enormous pressures to react on a purely economic model.
HEDRICK SMITH: Meaning?
Dr. HERB KRESSEL: Meaning why do we offer services that may not be
Dr. KIM SAAL: The finance committee needs to look at every part of our
business, be it the Joslin Clinic, be it a large physician practice, be it our
cardiac surgical, be it psychiatry, pediatrics, etc., dental clinics. Which
parts of the business should we continue in? Which parts of the business
should we excel in? And which parts of the business should we get out of?
HEDRICK SMITH: What do you have to balance off? The survival of an
Dr. HERB KRESSEL: Yes. The survival of the institution. If we don't
generate the funds required to carry out the mission, the institution doesn't
exist. So the problem that I have to face is what services do we stop doing
that enable us to carry out a good portion of the mission? And that's not a
very welcome thought.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] But Jim Reinertsen, the head of
CareGroup, believes there's still waste to be cut from the system.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: I hear a lot from nurses and from doctors and
pharmacists, "We can't go any faster. We can't cut any more or we will- we
will start hurting quality." And when I hear that, I listen to what they're
saying, and I'll often ask them a question that goes something like this.
"Well, tell me"-
[to nurse] -what could we do to take away parts of your day that you
regard as a waste of your time?
Oh, yeah! [laughs] The answer will come back, "Let me tell you about"-
and they'll start to tell you about something that's a complete waste of
HEDRICK SMITH: Hospitals are notoriously inefficient. Orders are
copied out by hand. Forms must be filled out in duplicate and triplicate. But
when we went with Dr. Reinertsen to visit a floor, this nurse expressed concern
not about paperwork, but about her patient load.
NURSE: Well, it's difficult to say because I don't think it's so much
that I waste time doing things that aren't important, more so that I spend a
lot of time doing a lot of things that are important for a number of
PATIENT: They don't have the time anymore.
HEDRICK SMITH: This patient echoed the nurse's worry.
PATIENT: Well, there have been a lot of changes since I first started
coming here because of all the merging and the cutbacks. And I think the
cutbacks in the nursing staff have been difficult.
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: People are reacting to fear of what might be the
new way and hanging on to the old way. We have to jar the organization out of
its complacency and say, "We have an urgent problem. We have to address it.
We have to be resolute about it. We have to move through this very
The biggest problem is making sure that we maintain- we establish and maintain
a sense of urgency without going all the way over into a state of panic.
HEDRICK SMITH: Marty Solomon senses the urgency of the times and feels
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: We've gone from the Mecca of medicine to a medical
Beirut, and it's really a tragedy. I think it's really destroyed medical care
HEDRICK SMITH: No longer protected from financial risk, doctors in
Boston and elsewhere are being asked to save money, patient by patient. And
increasingly, the incentives take aim on their personal incomes.
Dr. TOM DELBANCO, Chief of General Medicine: When I was young, if I did
more and more things to you, I got paid more. Now, as I'm older, if I do less
and less things for you, I may get paid more. Both of those extremes are
HEDRICK SMITH: The financial risk taken on by Boston hospitals is being
passed down to the doctors through the pods. Saving money for the system means
saving money for themselves. CareGroup medical director Kim Saal explains.
Dr. KIM SAAL: Financially, they are incentivized together. So at the
end of the year, if they're in surplus, they share in that surplus. If they're
in deficit, they share in that deficit.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So the pods are really organized as
a system of local financial accountability.
Dr. KIM SAAL: Absolutely correct.
HEDRICK SMITH: That's what it is.
Dr. KIM SAAL: That's exactly what it is.
HEDRICK SMITH: Yeah.
[voice-over] For the doctors in Pod 11 - whose salaries run from
$120,000 to $300,000 a year - the best way to protect their pay is to limit
their patients' choice. So when patients see specialists outside of CareGroup,
it raises a red flag.
PHYSICIAN: [pod meeting] Dr. Goldberg, you had a patient that
went to Metro West for derm, and I was wondering if this was because of an
access problem or-
HEDRICK SMITH: So today it falls to the doctors - not the HMOs - to
keep patients within their system.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: It's very hard to convince patients to stay within
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So why should they stay within the
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, they should because that's the way their
insurance plan is written.
HEDRICK SMITH: No, their insurance plan lets them go, doesn't it?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: No, it only lets them go if we allow them to go.
That's the catch.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Dr. Philip Boulter of Tufts Health
Plan admits that his HMO sells the idea of choice to attract customers.
Dr. PHILIP BOULTER, HMO Chief Medical Officer: We sell a product that
says you can go anywhere within Tufts Health Plan, and that may be to this
academic institution or quite a different one.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: The insurance company doesn't care because they
don't pay for it. I do.
Dr. PHILIP BOULTER: And patient gets caught in the middle. And worse,
the physician/patient relationship gets challenged under those circumstances.
Are you really serving my best interest as a patient doctor, or in fact, are
you looking out for your best interest? And that is a big challenge.
HEDRICK SMITH: Patients going to doctors out of the CareGroup network
are a constant topic at pod meetings.
Dr. SUSAN FRANKL: [pod meeting] People showing up to doctors
for specialty care, and you say, "Oh, you have to call first."
KATZ: Out of network?
Dr. SUSAN FRANKL: Out of network. And you know, "I didn't know. I
Dr. BILL GOLDBERG, Pod 11 Doctor: Then they call the insurer, and the
insurer says, "No, your doctor's telling you the wrong information. You can go
to the other doctor." And that's what happens over and over again.
Dr. KATZ: Do you have a general approach, anybody?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, my approach is that if it's truly an urgent
problem and there's no way that I can deal with it that day, and they sort of
talk me into believing that they didn't know it was the rules, I say, "This
visit. No subsequent visits. Follow-up visits will be within our provider
group." You can say no. It's okay.
HEDRICK SMITH: But saying no carries a price, as Solomon has
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: A perfect example is a patient of mine, a very
painful story about a patient of mine, a young woman with a gynecologic
malignancy who had done a lot of research on her own. And she found that there
was a group here in Boston at a different provider group hospital that had a
lot of experience treating this particular malignancy.
HEDRICK SMITH: In the days of cooperation between hospitals, Solomon
would have gladly sent her wherever she wanted to go. But not now.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: That would be coming right out of our budget, a very
substantial amount of money.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So your hospital's paying the other
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Our hospital's paying the other hospital, I'm paying
the other physician. That's coming out of our pocket to pay for this. But she
did the research, and she thought this was where she should go. And I
understood that. But I also understood that I could not allow her to go
HEDRICK SMITH: So what'd she say to you about money? I mean, did she
accuse you of making a decision for money reasons?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, she said, "So you're not letting me do this
because of money." Well, my response to that, usually, when people say that
is, "Of course! What do you think it is," you know? "If it was just medical
care, I'd let you go wherever you want, but this is a contract, and I'm not in
the business of subsidizing your care." [www.pbs.org: Should your care cost
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Eventually, his patient jumped to a
primary care physician at Brigham and Women's hospital, bitterly ending a
14-year relationship with Solomon. And to Solomon, losing a patient isn't even
the biggest problem.
[on-camera] Can you honestly say that you could go from a system where
you could pick any doctor in any institution anywhere, and now you've got to
stay within the team, that doesn't affect, at least in a few cases, the quality
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I'm sure it affects the quality of care. I'm
certain it affects the quality of care.
HEDRICK SMITH: Negatively?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Absolutely.
HEDRICK SMITH: And from the perspective of the individual patient?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: And from the perspective of the patient, they may
not be getting necessarily the best care. Absolutely.
HEDRICK SMITH: And what's your reaction to that?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I think it stinks.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] Dr. Solomon has another problem -
JOHN HUMPHRYS, Son: Did you get your medication before you came
HEDRICK SMITH: Lillian Humphrys is 84.
JOHN HUMPHRYS: Does your leg still hurt?
LILLIAN HUMPHRYS: My leg still pains.
HEDRICK SMITH: Like many seniors, she suffers from a number of
conditions- colon cancer, heart disease, mild dementia. Her son, John, and her
daughter, Beverly, have taken on the increasing burdens of her care. One step
was to sign her up for a Medicare HMO called Secure Horizons.
BEVERLY BUTLER, Daughter: So I thought, "Well, this should be a good
plan for her," very easy to take care of. Her primary care physician was in
there. She could go to the doctor's office for $5, be over and done with. I
thought it should work perfectly fine for her.
HEDRICK SMITH: But most patients don't understand the financial terms
that physicians accept under these plans. Many, like Secure Horizons,
represent the most extreme form of financial risk for the doctors. It is
called "global capitation," meaning patient care is paid for out of a pool of
money that goes to the pod.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: If the hospital is going to make a commitment to
continuing in Secure Horizons, then we'd like them to protect us.
HEDRICK SMITH: The doctors are totally - or globally - responsible for
all costs of care. Any money left over is paid out to the doctors. That idea
attracted Pod 11.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: There were plans involved in globally capitated
contracts around the country that were raking in millions of dollars.
HEDRICK SMITH: So Solomon and his pod signed up for Secure Horizons.
Dr. JEFFREY BASS, Pod 11 Doctor: At first we did pretty well. Maybe it
was luck. Maybe it was skill. But we did fairly well at first.
HEDRICK SMITH: But many practices run into trouble with Medicare HMOs,
according to Andrew Brotman.
ANDREW BROTMAN, Former VP, CareGroup: As the population ages, as the
patients get sicker, as more and more people come in to managed Medicare and
have more and more medical problems and as the rates come down, they find that
what they were doing two or three years ago is no longer successful.
HEDRICK SMITH: In fact, at rival Brigham and Women's Hospital, doctors
were losing so much money that they dropped the plan, leaving hundreds of
seniors scrambling for care.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, I was appalled when they did it. I just- I
think most of us in Boston were appalled when they did it.
HEDRICK SMITH: But now Solomon and his Pod 11 mates face the same grim
Dr. JEFFREY BASS: Despite our best efforts now, we're starting to lose
the financial war.
HEDRICK SMITH: During the six months we followed Solomon, Lillian
Humphrys was in and out of the hospital three times. Each time, Solomon was
caught between the family's demands to keep her in and his pod's economic
Lillian Humphrys brings $5,000 in premiums each year to Pod 11, but four days
in the hospital consumes that money. Any more and she means red ink.
During one of Mrs. Humphrys' prolonged stints in the hospital, Solomon pleaded
with the hospital staff to discharge her to a rehab center or assisted
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: [on the phone] I can't keep her in the
hospital any longer. She's in a globally capitated plan, which means that
we're paying for every day in the hospital out of our budget and she doesn't
need to be there.
HEDRICK SMITH: Over the past year, John Humphrys has become
increasingly frustrated with her care.
JOHN HUMPHRYS: And we would come in, and she'd be in the emergency room
for three or four hours, and they didn't want to admit her. Dr. Solomon had
said to us, on some of these times we were taking her in and I'm complaining to
him that she should be hospitalized, "Why is she coming home so early?" he's,
you know, specifically said if it wasn't for Secure Horizons, she'd be in the
HEDRICK SMITH: Some weeks later, Lillian was hospitalized once
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I've already lost money on this patient. Anything I
do for this patient now is money that is going to be subtracted from us.
HEDRICK SMITH: Pod 11 has many more patients like Lillian driving the
group into the red on Secure Horizons. Dr. Susan Frankl delivers the bad
Dr. SUSAN FRANKL: [pod meeting] We are in deficit by a fair
amount. We will not only have to- you know, it will be as though we provided
completely free care for all of these patients, and then in addition, paid
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: We will have to pay out-
Dr. SUSAN FRANKL: That's right.
PHYSICIAN: We should not be providing insurance. We are providing
service as physicians to care for these patients. It's not up to us to- you
know, to bail out somebody who got dreadfully ill. It wasn't our fault. We're
trying to take care of the patient. So why should we be penalized for it?
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] At the end of the year, what's that
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Well, it means that if we continue to lose money
beyond what's coming in, we actually have to give money back to the insurance
HEDRICK SMITH: You write them a check?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: We write them a check. We physicians write checks
that go back to the insurance company.
HEDRICK SMITH: And it comes out of your back pocket?
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: Out of our pocket.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] In the end, Pod 11's doctors did
have to pay money to the insurance company.
ANDREW BROTMAN, Former VP, CareGroup: And many of them will walk away
from these contracts and basically say, "We are not going to do this anymore.
We can't do this anymore. It's too much of an economic risk to our whole
Dr. JEFFREY BASS, Pod 11 Doctor: There's no company in the world that
can generate a product, lose money and stay in business.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] So what do you do?
Dr. JEFFREY BASS: At a certain point, you turn to the patient and say,
you know, "We've done the best we can for you. Unfortunately, it's been
difficult to take care of you under this health plan because we've lost money.
And we've made a group decision, albeit a very difficult one, but we've made a
group decision that maybe we need to withdraw from the plan."
BEVERLY BUTLER: I feel it's become very impersonal. I think the
patient is a number for most doctors. Yes, they want to help when they can,
but you're still a number to them. I don't think it's the old- the doctor of
the years ago. Not today. It's business today.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] A business that makes doctors like
Marty Solomon very uncomfortable.
Dr. MARTY SOLOMON: I don't think it's a good strategy for doctors to be
involved in the financial aspect of care at all except to understand what the
costs are in an effort to keep the costs down. Once we are put at risk,
there's no way you can deny that that's going to affect the way you're going to
make decisions. I don't care how much you fool yourself. At some level, it
has to affect the way you make decisions. And we should be making decisions
solely based on what's best for the patient.
HEDRICK SMITH: Hospital CEO Herb Kressel was also troubled by the
threat to the mission of care that he saw in the relentless pressure to cut
Dr. HERB KRESSEL, Pres., Beth Israel Deaconess: I think the point is
we're in danger of going too far. We're just starting to see people reaching a
limit. We're seeing hospitals closing. We're seeing people not able to
fulfill the mission, or a thing that I think we find an awful thought,
abandoning the mission.
HEDRICK SMITH: Soon after I interviewed Kressel, the board of trustees,
dissatisfied with the pace of change under his stewardship, asked for his
resignation. Jim Reinertsen took direct control of Beth Israel Deaconess, as
well as CareGroup.
Dr. ANDREW BROTMAN: His marching orders from the board are to restore a
balanced budget within a year.
HEDRICK SMITH: [on-camera] But that means cutting some mission.
Dr. ANDREW BROTMAN: That means cutting some mission. That means
perhaps not doing things that have been done for decades, even though they're
good things. That means decreasing support to things like teaching, research
Dr. JAMES REINERTSEN: There's no question but what things are different
and that there are many people grieving for what used to be. And perhaps the
best advice I've had to people who- who perseverate in that kind of grieving
is, "Get over it." It's already happened. We need to start building the new
institution. We can't go back to the old.
HEDRICK SMITH: [voice-over] This battle over the fate of
medicine can leave patients and their families feeling more like numbers than
individuals in need- the unpredictable, the elderly and the dying.
After 67 days in Beth Israel, Sam Armstrong lost the fight for his life. The
final hospital bill totaled $619,000. And for 1999, Armstrong appears as
number 3 on Martin Solomon's list of most expensive patients.
A FRONTLINE coproduction with
Hedrick Smith Productions, Inc.
in association with
South Carolina Educational TV
Copyright 2000 HEDRICK SMITH PRODUCTIONS, INC.
WGBH EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
ANNOUNCER: For more about doctors cutting costs by controlling care,
visit FRONTLINE's Web site, where FRONTLINE's producers will answer your
questions about this report, experts analyze pros and cons of running health
care as a business, tips on what to ask your doctor concerning his or her
financial interest in the practice, and much more at pbs.org or America Online
Next time, a NOVA/FRONTLINE special report. From record heat to raging storms,
something weird is going on with the weather.
Vice Pres. AL GORE: Global warming is real.
ANNOUNCER: Or is it?
FRED PALMER, Western Fuels Association, Inc.: There is no basis to say
that more CO2 in the air is going to lead to catastrophic global warming.
ANNOUNCER: PBS's premier science and investigative series join forces
to investigate the truth about global warming. ["What's Up With the
Educators and educational institutions can purchase this tape from PBS Video by
Now your letters. Our program on hate crimes against gay men and the brutal
murder of Billy Jack Gaither ["Assault on Gay America"] drew mixed but
strong reactions. Here is a sample.
NAME WITHHELD: [Hudson, NY] Dear FRONTLINE: It's a pity that
your usual high standards were not met for this deceptively important issue.
You spent a great deal of time laying out the sordid details of the crimes
committed and were rather thin on exploring your supposed subject of what is
really behind anti-gay violence ... The acceptance and understanding of
homosexuality ... is a tremendous act of strength and courage... Those who
manage to accomplish it are the real men.
TERRI McCLAIN: [St. Louis, MO] I wish FRONTLINE had offered the
viewpoint of an unbiased historian... Quite honestly, many people who are
tolerant of gay persons consider homosexual activity repulsive, and it is not
the result of any sexual repression on their part. I'm also repulsed by the
thought of eating raw oysters. That doesn't mean I harbor a secret desire to
indulge in them.
CHUCK COLLINS: [Farmington, MO] Billy Jack's brother showed a
wonderful display of love, compassion and understanding. That is what being a
man is all about. Although I respect Jerry Falwell's right to an opinion, I
feel that it is time he stop judging homosexuals and leave it in God's
ANNOUNCER: We'd like to know what you thought about tonight's program.
Drop us an email [email@example.com], a fax [(617) 300-1001], or a letter [DEAR
FRONTLINE, 125 Western Ave., Boston, MA 02134].
Major funding for this program was provided by the Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation and by the California HealthCare Foundation.
FRONTLINE is made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers
like you. Thank you.
FRONTLINE is made possible on GBH by the financial support of members like you,
in partnership with the Nstar companies - Boston Edison, ComElectric, ComGas,
Cambridge Electric. You can visit us on the Web at nstaronline.com. And with
Lexus. Roads? We don't need no stinking roads. Lexus is a proud sponsor of
inside the dilemma ·
financial incentives ·
cost v. care
ask the producer ·
producer's notebook ·
tapes & transcripts ·