Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

What should be done about racist depictions in the “Little House” books?

By Liz Fields

To many fans, the “Little House” book series, based on Laura Ingalls Wilder’s life on the western frontier, captures the spirit of America. The stories tell a tale of adventure, of quiet resilience in the face of extremes, the excitement of the unknown, and of re-settling and making something of oneself wherever one might land. These stories, of course, were written from one particular perspective. The other perspective is from those Native Americans whose land was stolen and populations decimated to accommodate the so-called “settlers,” but that version is too often ignored. It’s little wonder then that for some authors of color, the books spark both memories of warmth for their literary genius, and also sadness and anger for their troubling depictions of Native and Black Americans.

Writer Roxane Gaye.

“I think I first started reading the books in 1981, so we had very different sensibilities then,” said author and essayist Roxane Gay. “It didn’t even occur to anyone to think anything of the depictions of Indians in those books. And I think that’s deeply unfortunate and it shows just how much work we had to do with regards to recognizing the racism of those books.”

The collection of eight young adult books, which have been read by millions and shared among generations of families around the world, contain several dehumanizing descriptions of Native and Black characters. In one passage in “Little House on the Prairie,” Wilder wrote, “There were no people; only Indians lived there,” while in another, one of the characters, Pa, says, “the only good Indian is a dead Indian.” In “Little Town on the Prairie,” Pa appears in a minstrel show and sings a racist song — an anecdote accompanied by an illustration of the characters in blackface.

“There’s a passage in which Laura is fascinated by an Indian baby’s very dark eyes,” recalled children’s author Linda Sue Park who grew up reading the “Little House” books. “I had very dark eyes. So in my childhood mind, when Ma said horrible things about Native Americans, it felt like she was saying horrible things about me.”

“I was hurt by those books, and that took me fifty years to reconcile,” said Park. “Because the books that we love as children, they’re part of us. Right? They’re so much a part of our identity.”

In some instances, racist passages in the “Little House” series were amended in newer editions by book sellers. The ongoing controversy also prompted the American Library Association to rename its Laura Ingalls Wilder Lifetime Achievement Award to the Children’s Literature Legacy Award in 2018.

But some maintain that removing the most disturbing references or calling to ban the books entirely won’t mitigate the problem of pervasive racism and America’s inability to reckon with its own white revisionist history.

“I know some colleagues have said that they wish those scenes would be cut from new versions of the book. I don’t agree with that,” said Wilder biographer Pamela Smith Hill. “It’s very disturbing, but it is part of our history, and if we don’t talk about these issues honestly with our children we are jeopardizing their future and the future of our country.”

Gay, who has previously written about how the “Little House” books shaped her life from the time she was a young girl in Nebraska, remembers the books as engaging, beautifully written and charming, despite their damaging portrayals of Native and Black characters.

“I can remember details from those books, literally, f– almost 40 years later,” she said. “I still remember the book the first time I read it clear as day — and I can’t say that for books I read last week.

“The books just have to be taught in context, and the proper context, not revisionist context.”

SHARE
Features
Laura Ingalls Wilder documentary
Passport
Full Episode | Laura Ingalls Wilder: Prairie to Page
The subtle libertarian politics of Laura Ingalls Wilder’s “Little House” books
The subtle libertarian politics of Laura Ingalls Wilder’s “Little House” books
The letter from NY that changed Laura Ingalls Wilder’s life
Clip | The letter from NY that changed Laura Ingalls Wilder’s life
Laura Ingalls Wilder, 1951.
8 Interesting facts about Laura Ingalls Wilder
What’s it like to attend “Laurapalooza,” the conference for Laura Ingalls Wilder superfans (“bonnetheads”)?
What’s it like to attend “Laurapalooza,” the conference for Laura Ingalls Wilder superfans (“bonnetheads”)?
A “Little House” adulthood: How the books changed when I grew up
A “Little House” adulthood: How the books changed when I grew up
In promoting the “myth of white self-sufficiency,” the “Little House” books rewrite history
In promoting the “myth of white self-sufficiency,” the “Little House” books rewrite history
Covered wagon
Play Laura Ingalls Wilder bingo
Roxane Gay and others on racist “Little House” depictions
Clip | Roxane Gay and others on racist “Little House” depictions
Join the Laura Ingalls Wilder #ShareYourShelfieContest
Join the Laura Ingalls Wilder #ShareYourShelfieContest
The word that Laura refused to say in her wedding vows
Clip | The word that Laura refused to say in her wedding vows
Until she was an author, money was a struggle for Wilder
Clip | Until she was an author, money was a struggle for Wilder
The secret mother-daughter collaboration on “Little House”
Clip | The secret mother-daughter collaboration on “Little House”
Disaster was looming when the Ingalls moved to Minnesota
Clip | Disaster was looming when the Ingalls moved to Minnesota
How the logs of the “Little House” cabin were stolen
Clip | How the logs of the “Little House” cabin were stolen
A replica of the house that was described in the book "Little House in the Big Woods" near Pepin, Wisconsin.
How well do you know the life and work of Laura Ingalls Wilder? Test your knowledge with this expert quiz.
How well do you know the life and work of Laura Ingalls Wilder? Test your knowledge with this beginner quiz.
How well do you know the life and work of Laura Ingalls Wilder? Test your knowledge with this beginner quiz.
How well do you know the life and work of Laura Ingalls Wilder? Test your knowledge with this advanced quiz.
How well do you know the life and work of Laura Ingalls Wilder? Test your knowledge with this advanced quiz.
Laura Ingalls Wilder’s famous gingerbread recipe
Laura Ingalls Wilder’s famous gingerbread recipe
A replica of the house that was described in the book "Little House in the Big Woods" near Pepin, Wisconsin.
Laura Ingalls Wilder biographical timeline
Favorite quotes from the “Little House” books
Favorite quotes from the “Little House” books
Laura Ingalls Wilder’s 1916 column for Thanksgiving reminds us to “just be glad that we are alive”
Laura Ingalls Wilder’s 1916 column for Thanksgiving reminds us to “just be glad that we are alive”
Laura Ingalls Wilder, 1951.
10 of Laura Ingalls Wilder’s most inspiring quotes
127 songs are mentioned in the “Little House” books. This playlist presents many of them.
127 songs are mentioned in the “Little House” books. This playlist presents many of them.
A Laura Ingalls Wilder suggested reading list
A Laura Ingalls Wilder suggested reading list