Flashpoints USA with Bryant Gumbel and Gwen Ifill Photo: Bryant Gumbel and Gwen Ifill
In Focus Discuss For Educators Resources
God and Country - 1.27.04
DISCUSS: RELIGION AND THE LAW


God in America
Religion and the Law
The Politics of God



Comments are also viewable in our Featured Responses area. (This feature requires Flash 6.)

"A monument to the Ten Commandments should be allowed to stand in a state courthouse."
< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 >
Opinions
Total # of Responses: 642 - 2/7/04
51% 3% 1% 3% 41%

We have received feedback on this issue from people all across America. Review the graph to the left for a quick snapshot of the responses received to date, or read the responses below.

Allen, CA Strongly Disagree

... DO NOT WISH TO SEE GOD ...


January 28,2004

THIS IS A NON SECULAR COUNTRY. IRAN IS NOT. ALL YOU NEED TO DO IS LOOK AT THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE TWO. I KNOW THIS IS WHERE THE RELIGIOUS EXTREMISTS WOULD LIKE THIS, FORTUNATELY THE VAST MAJORITY OF US DO NOT. WHILE I BELIEVE IN GOD, I DO NOT WISH TO SEE GOD IN OUR COURTS OR GOVT. I CAN PRAY AND PRACTICE MY RELIGION AT HOME OR IN CHURCH. THST IS FREEDOM!

Allen, CA Strongly Disagree

... NON SECULAR COUNTRY ...


January 28,2004

THIS IS A NON SECULAR COUNTRY. IRAN IS NOT. ALL YOU NEED TO DO IS LOOK AT THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE TWO. I KNOW THIS IS WHERE THE RELIGIOUS EXTREMISTS WOULD LIKE THIS, FORTUNATELY THE VAST MAJORITY OF US DO NOT. WHILE I BELIEVE IN GOD, I DO NOT WISH TO SEE GOD IN OUR COURTS OR GOVT. I CAN PRAY AND PRACTICE MY RELIGION AT HOME OR IN CHURCH. THIS IS FREEDOM!

Christophe, AK Strongly Disagree

... beliefs of the First Americans ...


January 28,2004

How about putting the beliefs of the First Americans into public practice? As an American Indian I am offended by these discussions which, once again, leave out the conquered people from any mainstream discussions.

Joey, CA Strongly Disagree

... direct opposition to democracy ...


January 28,2004

The Ten Commandments should not be displayed in any government building or public grounds. They are in direct opposition to democracy. They contradict the Bill of Rights and the 13th Ammendment
to the Constitution. For example, the First Commandment, 'Thou shalt have no other gods before me', violates the First Ammendment, i.e., Religious Freedom. The 10 Commandments are clearly of Judeo-Christian
origin. What about Budhists,
Hindus, Pantheists and Atheists? The 10 commandments
when put in context to are hideous and obscene. The Treaty of Tripoly, passed by Congress and signed into law by President Adams in 1797 states in Article 11, 'As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on
the Christian Religion,...'.
According to the Ten Commandments one should observe the sabbath and allow
one's slaves to do the same. This violates the 13th Ammendment. By today's standards it should be reviled. The authors of the Old Testament were sexist, anti-woman, anti-human, anti-life and anti-earth. They were on the same level of intellectual development as the Taliban is today.

George, CO Strongly Agree

... NO limit to our exposure ...


January 28,2004

The Constitution says "NO LAW". That means NO limit to our exposure to ideas. To limit our exposure to ideas, will limit our ability to make any kind of decision.

Dennis, OR Strongly Agree

... due to our faith in god ...


January 28,2004

The very strength of our country today is due to our faith in god. To declare what is right and wrong and stand upon that declaration is our past and our future.

Anais, OR Strongly Agree

... should not be allowed ...


January 28,2004

A monument to the Ten Commandments should not be allowed to stand in a state courthouse because that to me suggests endorsement of one religion, Christianity.

Bob, CO Strongly Disagree

... equal time and equal space ...


January 28,2004

Will the governement provide equal time and equal space to monuments of non-Christian spiritual beliefs. I doubt it. Even if they did, I guess I don't think our courthouses need to be museums to all the spiritual belief systems in the world. Seems to me that's what houses of worship are for.

Manuel, CA Strongly Agree

... nothing to be afraid of. ...


January 28,2004

Truth and goodness are nothing to be afraid of.

Kerry, OR Strongly Disagree

... all major religions ...


January 28,2004

If you really want some kind of ethical statement have representatives from all major religions plus non-religious representatives gather and put together a list of lessons to live by in a civilized society.

Roy King, CA Strongly Disagree

... no longer the consensus ...


January 28,2004

The previous homogeneous concept of "god" in this country is no longer the consensus. "God" should remain as a concept, that leads us as a country. However, "God" as defined by any ONE religion or any ONE culture or ONE race does not belong in US Government. The 10 commandments would appeal to christans and jews, but would be offensive to most others. The constitution applies to all americans. If our founding fathers had not been religiously oppressed by "government religion" (i.e. "The Church of England") they would have had little reason to leave their homeland.

Charlie, AK Strongly Disagree

... government to display ...


January 28,2004

The problem I have with displaying the ten commandments in a public place is the line "I am the lord thy God". That is a message that tells any person who reads it they have a god and a SPECIFIC god at that. It is illegal for the government to display such blatent public endorsement of a particular religion.

Sophia, CA Strongly Agree

... sense of responsibility ...


January 28,2004

Absolutely this is the base of what the law defends not one of us as humans want a love one or someone dear to us to be robbed, killed etc... What is the purpose of anyone willing to take such a message away is unimaginable. If these laws of the 10 commandments were followed we would be less afraid to think of the what if someone... The 10 commandments is not just a religious monument unless this is the only way one chooses to see it as, it is a sense of responsibility, a respect for others it is and should be everyone’s will follow a guild line so factual and decent. WE should all be reminded of these commandments, is anyone considering hello maybe just maybe less crime on you even.

Randy Tric, CA Strongly Agree

... pure and simple ...


January 28,2004

these are the ten commandments, not the ten suggestions. pure and simple......

Jim, AK Strongly Agree

... more from the Judge ...


January 28,2004

Wow! Let's hear more from the Judge. He makes a good case.

Jo, OR Strongly Disagree

... None belong in a courthouse ...


January 28,2004

If we allow one, we have to allow them all. None belong in a courthouse. I'd hate to be a Muslim being tried by an intolerant Christian, and how can we believe it would be otherwise with overt statements like monuments of the Ten Commandments were allowed to stand?

Karin, CA Strongly Agree

... founded on Christian principles. ...


January 28,2004

Our country was founded on Christian principles.

Robert, OR Strongly Agree

... should be allowed ...


January 28,2004

I strongly agree that a monument of the ten commandments should be allowed in a courthouse, along with being in schoolhouses or any other public building.

Jack, TX Strongly Agree

... founded on Christian principles ...


January 28,2004

This great nation was founded on Christian principles. The Ten Commandments, in general, are outstanding rules by which to live. Where better to have them stand than in a courthouse?

Karl, OR Strongly Disagree

... respect the rights of others ...


January 28,2004

As a Christian, I continue to work hard at maintaining the separation of church and state. As a Christian, it is one of my utmost responsibilities to respect the rights of others to believe in the god of their choice, or no god at all.

< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 >

Copyright © 2004 GWETA. All rights reserved.