By — Larisa Epatko Larisa Epatko Leave your feedback Share Copy URL https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/twitter-mexico-drug-war Email Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Tumblr Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Twitter Chat: Fired Up and Fed Up With Mexico’s Drug War World Jun 27, 2012 5:05 PM EDT Margaret Warner in a mass grave site in Juarez, Mexico. Photo by Morgan Till/NewsHour. Just days before Mexicans vote for their next president on Sunday, one of the hottest topics on voters’ minds is the violence connected to drug-trafficking. On Wednesday, NewsHour senior correspondent Margaret Warner hosted a Twitter conversation from Mexico on what to do about the drug war. Five reporters and analysts with varying perspectives joined Warner for a conversation in English and Spanish at #MXdrugwar. We’ve posted some highlights. Participants included: Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan), a reporter with the Changing America Desk (@fronterasdesk); Cesar Rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez), a crime beat reporter for Tiempo de Laredo, Spanish-language edition of Laredo Morning Times (@LMTTiempo); Alejandro Madrazo Lajous (@BuenMadrazo), a research fellow at CIDE in Mexico; Sylvia Longmire (@drugwaranalyst), author of “Cartel – The Coming Invasion of Mexico’s Drug Wars”; and Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst), senior policy analyst covering Latin America at the Heritage Foundation (@Heritage). Warner opened the debate with this question: @MargaretWarner Everything needs to change. Calderon’s war has been a catastrophe from any perspective you look at it. #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 A1. Cartels need 2 be prioritized by threat. Zetas need 2 be eliminated ASAP, yes, at the cost of other cartels operating freely. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 A1. Another important task is to provide more educational and work opportunities for Mexico’s youth to keep them out of cartels. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 A1. One could argue the DTOs are so entrenched in MX politics by now that it doesn’t matter who’s in power. They’re here to stay. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 Power-sharing is a dangerously political word, we are delaing with criminal orgs #mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 What can be done about the criminal cartels? Q3: Several of you said concentrate security firepower to hammer the more violent cartels. What about the others? #mxdrugwar — Margaret Warner (@MargaretWarner) June 27, 2012 #mxdrugwar A3: Unfortunately, cells will always operate. The problem is stopping these cells from becoming cartels. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 Q3: @cesar_rodriguez said cells will always operate, but can stop them from becoming cartels. What do you mean? How do that ? #mxdrugwar — Margaret Warner (@MargaretWarner) June 27, 2012 @cesar_rodriguez If so, why does Mexico bare the burden of stopping drugs from getting to the US?#mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 Drug consumption in US drives problem but does not explain state weaknesss and extreme violence.#mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 Cartels don’t run out of ideas. One scheme has then recruiting US teens for small drug deliveries. If caught, they’re minors. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 What does the United States need to do? @heritageanalyst US govt does not consider #mxdrugwar to be a priority, which is part of the problem. Not mentioned in last 4 SOTU speeches. — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 @NewsHour @BuenMadrazo Mex is the first line of defense against #mxdrugwar. U.S. does their best to stop the smuggling at border. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 A1. In the mid term we need to move towards regulation of the drug markets, gradually and depending on the drug and the community #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 @BuenMadrazo Unfortunately, legalization requires withdrawal from UN Single Convention Against Narcotics. US will never do it. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 The topic came up of how the failed U.S. gun-running sting, dubbed Fast and Furious, affected dynamics between the two countries: The flow of weapons from US to Mexico is nothing new. It’s just drawing more attention now because of #FastandFurious scandal. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 @heritageanalyst Agreed. While F&F scandal is going on, people forget the guns are still going south and no progress being made. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 @MargaretWarner #mxdrugwar To stop the flow of weapons, more people are required at International Bridges at both sides of the border. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 @MargaretWarner US is clearly not interested in stoping guns going to Mexico. Why should we stop drugs going to US? #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 How is the drug question playing in Mexico’s elections? A9. It seems most candidates would rather not speak about it if given a choice, like US candidates with #immigration. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 A9: I’ve also read that some candidates are ignoring the issue. EPN’s ideas have been pretty vague with no concrete strategies. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 Q. 10.In Mexico, believe electorate will choose leader they hope will do best job, not the policy itself.#mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 A10. The downfall of the #PAN is amazing. Wonder how much Calderon’s failure to beat the cartels has pushed people away from PAN. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 The path ahead: @heritageanalyst US-Mexico should work together only if Mexico’s interests are also on the table (which they aren’t now). #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 Wednesday’s report on the NewsHour focused on the high costs of Mexico’s drug war: View all of the NewsHour team’s Mexico coverage. class=”twitter-follow-button” data-show-count=”false”>Follow @newshourworld We're not going anywhere. Stand up for truly independent, trusted news that you can count on! Donate now By — Larisa Epatko Larisa Epatko Larisa Epatko produced multimedia web features and broadcast reports with a focus on foreign affairs for the PBS NewsHour. She has reported in places such as Jordan, Pakistan, Iraq, Haiti, Sudan, Western Sahara, Guantanamo Bay, China, Vietnam, South Korea, Turkey, Germany and Ireland. @NewsHourWorld
Margaret Warner in a mass grave site in Juarez, Mexico. Photo by Morgan Till/NewsHour. Just days before Mexicans vote for their next president on Sunday, one of the hottest topics on voters’ minds is the violence connected to drug-trafficking. On Wednesday, NewsHour senior correspondent Margaret Warner hosted a Twitter conversation from Mexico on what to do about the drug war. Five reporters and analysts with varying perspectives joined Warner for a conversation in English and Spanish at #MXdrugwar. We’ve posted some highlights. Participants included: Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan), a reporter with the Changing America Desk (@fronterasdesk); Cesar Rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez), a crime beat reporter for Tiempo de Laredo, Spanish-language edition of Laredo Morning Times (@LMTTiempo); Alejandro Madrazo Lajous (@BuenMadrazo), a research fellow at CIDE in Mexico; Sylvia Longmire (@drugwaranalyst), author of “Cartel – The Coming Invasion of Mexico’s Drug Wars”; and Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst), senior policy analyst covering Latin America at the Heritage Foundation (@Heritage). Warner opened the debate with this question: @MargaretWarner Everything needs to change. Calderon’s war has been a catastrophe from any perspective you look at it. #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 A1. Cartels need 2 be prioritized by threat. Zetas need 2 be eliminated ASAP, yes, at the cost of other cartels operating freely. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 A1. Another important task is to provide more educational and work opportunities for Mexico’s youth to keep them out of cartels. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 A1. One could argue the DTOs are so entrenched in MX politics by now that it doesn’t matter who’s in power. They’re here to stay. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 Power-sharing is a dangerously political word, we are delaing with criminal orgs #mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 What can be done about the criminal cartels? Q3: Several of you said concentrate security firepower to hammer the more violent cartels. What about the others? #mxdrugwar — Margaret Warner (@MargaretWarner) June 27, 2012 #mxdrugwar A3: Unfortunately, cells will always operate. The problem is stopping these cells from becoming cartels. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 Q3: @cesar_rodriguez said cells will always operate, but can stop them from becoming cartels. What do you mean? How do that ? #mxdrugwar — Margaret Warner (@MargaretWarner) June 27, 2012 @cesar_rodriguez If so, why does Mexico bare the burden of stopping drugs from getting to the US?#mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 Drug consumption in US drives problem but does not explain state weaknesss and extreme violence.#mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 Cartels don’t run out of ideas. One scheme has then recruiting US teens for small drug deliveries. If caught, they’re minors. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 What does the United States need to do? @heritageanalyst US govt does not consider #mxdrugwar to be a priority, which is part of the problem. Not mentioned in last 4 SOTU speeches. — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 @NewsHour @BuenMadrazo Mex is the first line of defense against #mxdrugwar. U.S. does their best to stop the smuggling at border. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 A1. In the mid term we need to move towards regulation of the drug markets, gradually and depending on the drug and the community #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 @BuenMadrazo Unfortunately, legalization requires withdrawal from UN Single Convention Against Narcotics. US will never do it. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 The topic came up of how the failed U.S. gun-running sting, dubbed Fast and Furious, affected dynamics between the two countries: The flow of weapons from US to Mexico is nothing new. It’s just drawing more attention now because of #FastandFurious scandal. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 @heritageanalyst Agreed. While F&F scandal is going on, people forget the guns are still going south and no progress being made. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 @MargaretWarner #mxdrugwar To stop the flow of weapons, more people are required at International Bridges at both sides of the border. — cesar_rodriguez (@cesar_rodriguez) June 27, 2012 @MargaretWarner US is clearly not interested in stoping guns going to Mexico. Why should we stop drugs going to US? #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 How is the drug question playing in Mexico’s elections? A9. It seems most candidates would rather not speak about it if given a choice, like US candidates with #immigration. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 A9: I’ve also read that some candidates are ignoring the issue. EPN’s ideas have been pretty vague with no concrete strategies. #mxdrugwar — Sylvia Longmire (@DrugWarAnalyst) June 27, 2012 Q. 10.In Mexico, believe electorate will choose leader they hope will do best job, not the policy itself.#mxdrugwar — Ray Walser (@heritageanalyst) June 27, 2012 A10. The downfall of the #PAN is amazing. Wonder how much Calderon’s failure to beat the cartels has pushed people away from PAN. #mxdrugwar — Hernan Rozemberg (@scribehernan) June 27, 2012 The path ahead: @heritageanalyst US-Mexico should work together only if Mexico’s interests are also on the table (which they aren’t now). #mxdrugwar — Alejandro Madrazo L (@BuenMadrazo) June 27, 2012 Wednesday’s report on the NewsHour focused on the high costs of Mexico’s drug war: View all of the NewsHour team’s Mexico coverage. class=”twitter-follow-button” data-show-count=”false”>Follow @newshourworld We're not going anywhere. Stand up for truly independent, trusted news that you can count on! Donate now