
The Problem That Broke Physics (And Led to Chaos)
Clip: Season 53 | 6m 12sVideo has Closed Captions
The “butterfly effect” is often cited in pop culture, but it’s actually rooted in physics and chaos.
From Jurassic Park to TikTok trends, the “butterfly effect” has captivated the public imagination for a long time. But the idea that tiny actions can have big impacts on our lives and the world is actually rooted in physics — and chaos.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
National Corporate funding for NOVA is provided by Carlisle Companies. Major funding for NOVA is provided by the NOVA Science Trust and PBS viewers.

The Problem That Broke Physics (And Led to Chaos)
Clip: Season 53 | 6m 12sVideo has Closed Captions
From Jurassic Park to TikTok trends, the “butterfly effect” has captivated the public imagination for a long time. But the idea that tiny actions can have big impacts on our lives and the world is actually rooted in physics — and chaos.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch NOVA
NOVA is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.

NOVA Labs
NOVA Labs is a free digital platform that engages teens and lifelong learners in games and interactives that foster authentic scientific exploration. Participants take part in real-world investigations by visualizing, analyzing, and playing with the same data that scientists use.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- You've probably heard this one before: a butterfly flapping its wings in one place can lead to a tornado in a whole other part of the world.
That's the butterfly effect, and chances are you've seen it everywhere, from Jurassic Park to TikTok.
But its roots run way deeper than that, because the butterfly effect isn't just about how some small choice or event changed your life years down the road.
It's about chaos, math, and just how well we can know our complex, unpredictable world.
We'll come back to the butterfly effect, but first we need to back up to Isaac Newton, because after he described the laws of motion in the 1600s, the universe seemed straightforward, knowable, and predictable.
Then Newton ran into what's known as the Three-Body Problem.
He found that he could use math to predict Earth's path around the Sun using the starting position and velocity of both bodies.
But once he added a third body, like the Moon, there were too many variables, so he couldn't predict their future position and velocity.
Newton never did find the answer to the three-body problem.
Two centuries later, no one else had either.
Eventually, French mathematician Henri Poincare theorized that the problem had no practical solution, because of a concept called Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions.
The idea was that in some systems, even small differences and where something starts can dramatically change where it ends up, making prediction all but impossible.
That concept is central to Chaos Theory, which says that we can't definitively predict the position and action of every single atom, and therefore there are limits to what we can know.
For example, say I'm going to knead some walnuts into a bread dough- or a Play-Doh, because mess.
The more I work the dough, the more things move around and I'll never make the same bread twice.
Even small differences in where the walnuts were in the first place, or how many times I fold the dough could push the walnuts into a completely different spot in the dough.
And we can see this type of chaos in all kinds of systems.
From the motion of gas molecules to the path of a double pendulum to the staple of office small talk, (thunder booming) the weather, which brings us back to the butterfly effect.
In 1961, MIT meteorologist, Edward Lorenz was using a weather prediction program to simulate earth's atmosphere using equations.
At the time, most people thought weather prediction should be pretty straightforward.
If we look at enough historical data, we should be able to predict what will happen in the future.
But one day, Lorenz wanted to take a closer look at some of his data, so he reentered some numbers into the computer and in the process, the number 0.506127 was rounded to 0.506, a seemingly minor difference.
For a while, the resulting numbers followed the same pattern as the original, but then they changed, eventually predicting completely different weather.
Lorenz tried all sorts of experiments to see if he could shift that trajectory and produce a run where small changes didn't ultimately lead to big differences.
But eventually he theorized that tiny actions could impact something dynamic, like weather forecasts resulting in large scale changes.
In 1972, Lorenz gave a presentation called "Predictability: Does the Flap of a Butterfly's Wings in Brazil Set Off a Tornado in Texas?"
And there you have it, the butterfly effect was born.
People have gone on to debate whether or not it's literally true that a butterfly can set off a tornado, but either way, it's a helpful analogy for describing sensitive dependence on initial conditions.
The butterfly effect helps us understand just how unpredictable systems like the weather can be.
Small changes or errors in the way a weather station measures temperature or humidity could lead to wildly different weather forecasts.
But that doesn't mean these systems are entirely unknowable.
There are mathematical tools that help us describe and find overall patterns and trajectories in chaos.
For example, differential equations relate one or more variables to the rate that the same variables change and fractals are complex repeating patterns created by repeating a process or equation over and over.
With these tools, we can visualize, analyze, and begin to make sense of unpredictable systems.
Which is why we have weather forecasts at all.
Since the 1950s, we've made huge technological advances in weather forecasting.
We've got satellites that help us track atmospheric trends and supercomputers that use complicated models and equations to simulate weather conditions and make predictions.
We also use ensemble forecasting where multiple models with slight variations are compared to estimate a range of possible outcomes.
The spaghetti plots you see during hurricane season are an example of how we can visualize this ensemble forecasting.
And when more of the outcomes look similar, the more confident forecasters are.
So the first three to five days of a forecast can usually give us a pretty accurate idea of whether we will need, say, a sweater or not.
Beyond that, things get complicated again.
More than 10 days out, there are too many variables, so forecasting is mostly guesswork.
And as we move even farther out into the future, and as climate change drives extreme weather events, even more variables are introduced and forecasting future conditions becomes even more complex.
But that's not to say we won't get there.
Our world is made up of intricate patterns and structures that can show us connections between seemingly random events, systems, and outcomes.
And these patterns can help make even the most complex unknowable problems, something we can continue to trace, model, consider, and try to understand.
So when it comes to our ability to solve the unsolvable and predict the unpredictable, who knows what the future might hold.
(light music)
Why Earth’s Core Is Younger Than Its Surface
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 | 6m | Time isn’t the same for everyone, according to Einstein. (6m)
The Truth about Quantum Computers
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 | 6m 44s | Microsoft's breakthrough in quantum computing could have a huge impact on science, and our future. (6m 44s)
The Problem That Broke Physics (And Led to Chaos)
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 | 6m 12s | The “butterfly effect” is often cited in pop culture, but it’s actually rooted in physics and chaos. (6m 12s)
The Ocean Wave Scientists Thought Was Impossible
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 | 5m 46s | These massive walls of water may be far more common than we once believed. (5m 46s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep7 | 30s | Follow the Artemis mission to bring humanity back to the Moon for the first time since Apollo. (30s)
Athens: Birth of Democracy Preview
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep8 | 30s | Archaeologists investigate the dramatic origins of democracy in ancient Greece 2,500 years ago. (30s)
Stone Age Temple Mystery Preview
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep6 | 30s | Surprising evidence at the world’s oldest temple overturns our understanding of human history. (30s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep5 | 30s | A deadly—and growing—global weather phenomenon mystifies scientists. (30s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep4 | 30s | Explore mammals’ surprising origins, long before the age of dinosaurs. (30s)
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep3 | 30s | Do speech buttons really allow dogs to talk to us? Scientists investigate. (30s)
Angkor: Hidden Jungle Empire Preview
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep2 | 30s | New evidence sheds light on the remarkable life—and mysterious collapse—of the ancient jungle city. (30s)
When Earth Was Bombarded by Asteroids
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 Ep1 | 3m 41s | What studying the surface of the Moon revealed about Earth’s apocalyptic youth. (3m 41s)
Asteroids: Spark of Life? Preview
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S53 Ep1 | 30s | What if violent asteroid impacts actually jump-started life on Earth? Explore a dramatic theory. (30s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
- Science and Nature

Capturing the splendor of the natural world, from the African plains to the Antarctic ice.

- Science and Nature

An unforgettable journey of the majestic Colorado River and the urgent fight to protect its future.

New Season
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode




Support for PBS provided by:
National Corporate funding for NOVA is provided by Carlisle Companies. Major funding for NOVA is provided by the NOVA Science Trust and PBS viewers.














